Summary#
Introduction 0387-2026, sponsored by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, would amend the New York City Administrative Code to require the Department of Homeless Services (DHS) commissioner to report shelter crime statistics and security information. Its stated goal is to provide information about critical incidents and shelter security. It has been laid over in the Committee on General Welfare and is not law.
- DHS would have to send an annual report to the Council Speaker and post it on the department’s website.
- Reports would list the number of “critical incidents” by type. The list includes assault, sexual assault, domestic violence, child abuse or neglect, weapons possession, arson and theft, but is not limited to those incidents. DHS designates which incidents it tracks as critical.
- Reports would describe security improvements, security agreements with the Police Department or other law enforcement entities, and security at each shelter, including peace officers, private guards or no security measures.
- Information would be broken down by shelter population and, for family shelters, by Tier II shelters, cluster sites and hotels.
- Reporting must not violate privacy laws, interfere with investigations or otherwise conflict with law enforcement interests.
What it means for you#
- Shelter residents: The bill would require public reporting about incidents and security, but does not create a new security service or promise a particular level of security.
- DHS: The commissioner would have to prepare and publish the reports. The bill says reporting was to begin no later than July 31, 2022, and recur each July 31; it would take effect immediately. The 2022 date is earlier than this bill’s introduction.
- Shelter providers: The bill covers shelters run by DHS and shelters run by providers under contract or a similar agreement with DHS. It does not specify new duties for providers.
- General public: The report would be public on DHS’s website, subject to the privacy and law-enforcement limits.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires DHS to produce and publish reports, but gives no estimate of staffing, reporting or other costs.
- It does not set a fee, fine, or new payment.
What is unclear#
- The bill sets a reporting start date in 2022 but does not say how DHS should handle reports for earlier years if the bill takes effect later.
- “Critical incident” includes a list of examples, but DHS decides what incidents it tracks and designates as critical. The text does not set detailed rules for that decision.
- The bill does not set a method for checking the accuracy or completeness of reported data.
- It is unclear how much information may be withheld under the privacy and law-enforcement limits.
- The current Administrative Code text was not supplied, so the available material does not show what shelter reporting requirements already exist or how much this bill would add.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make information about shelter incidents and security available to the Council and the public.
- Requiring breakdowns by incident type, shelter population and individual shelter could make the reported information more specific than a citywide total.
- Reporting security staffing and agreements could help readers understand what security measures are present, without requiring DHS to adopt a particular measure.
Case against#
- One concern is that DHS controls which incidents it tracks and designates as critical, while the bill does not set detailed standards for those decisions.
- The privacy and law-enforcement exceptions could limit what the public sees; the bill does not explain how those limits would be applied.
- The bill requires annual reporting but does not specify checks on data quality or consequences for missing or incomplete reports.