Establishing an office of black male excellence

Summary#

Introduction 0413-2026, sponsored by Council Member Kevin C. Riley, would amend the New York City Charter. It would require the Mayor to establish an Office of Black Male Excellence; its stated goal is to analyze issues Black males face and recommend improvements.

  • The office could be standalone or placed within the Mayor’s Office or a city agency; it would not have to be a separate independent agency.
  • A director appointed by the Mayor—or by an agency head if the office is placed in that agency—would analyze issues and make recommendations to the Mayor, Council, and relevant agencies.
  • The director would also serve as a liaison to city agencies and the public on those issues. The bill lists education, criminal justice, health, mental health, economic opportunity, employment, fatherhood, mentorship, violence, public safety, and quality of life, among other issues.
  • The office would have to report each year by January 31 to the Mayor and Council Speaker, and post the report online. It would cover the previous calendar year’s work and include counts of people who interacted with it, broken down by demographic and geographic information.
  • The law would take effect 180 days after it becomes law. The bill has only been introduced and referred to a Council committee; it is waiting there and is not law.

What it means for you#

  • Black men and the public: The office would be a liaison and make recommendations, but the bill does not create a new benefit, service, or right for individuals. It does not require anyone to apply or interact with the office.
  • City agencies and officials: The Mayor would have to establish the office. The office would make recommendations, but the bill does not require the Mayor, Council, or agencies to adopt them.
  • City government: The office would have to publish its annual report, including the required counts and recommendations.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Mayor to establish the office and requires a director, but gives no staffing plan, budget, or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “Black male” or explain how the office would identify people for its reported counts.
  • It does not set rules for how people can contact the office, how their information would be collected, or how it would be protected.
  • It does not say what staff or funding the office would have, or how the office’s recommendations would be handled.
  • The Council materials say the bill was referred to a committee but do not name the committee.

Case for#

  • The Council summary identifies socioeconomic issues faced by Black males as the problem the office would address. A dedicated office could focus analysis and recommendations on the listed issues.
  • The bill would require the office to act as a liaison with city agencies and the public, and to report its work each year.
  • Requiring recommendations to acknowledge inequities could make those inequities part of the office’s analysis.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the office authority to analyze, recommend, and serve as a liaison, but does not require other city officials or agencies to act on its recommendations.
  • The office’s placement is left to the Mayor, and the bill does not specify its staffing or funding.
  • The bill covers a wide range of issues but does not define key terms or set out how the office would choose its priorities.