Prohibiting developers receiving city financial assistance from restricting pet ownership in dwelling units offered for rent in housing development projects

Summary#

Introduction 0435-2026, sponsored by Council Member Lynn C. Schulman, would amend the New York City Administrative Code by adding rules for pets in some rental housing development projects receiving city financial assistance. Its stated goal is to prevent developers from banning pets in those projects. The bill was introduced and referred to committee on January 29, 2026; it is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • A covered developer and its agent could not include or enforce a lease term banning pets in covered rental units; such a term would be void and unenforceable.
  • The rule would cover newly assisted housing development projects subject to a government regulatory agreement, with specified exclusions. It would not apply to assistance received before the law takes effect or to leases entered into before then.
  • The bill preserves a developer’s or agent’s right to bring an eviction or possession action if a pet causes damage, creates a nuisance, or substantially interferes with other occupants’ health, safety, or welfare.
  • If enacted, it would take effect 240 days after becoming law.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants in covered units: A lease term banning pets would not be enforceable under this bill. “Pet” includes dogs, cats, and other domesticated animals normally kept in or near a household, but not farm or wild animals.
  • Developers and their agents: They would have to avoid including or enforcing pet bans in covered leases. The bill does not prevent them from bringing a case based on a pet’s damage, nuisance, or substantial interference with other occupants.
  • Tenants with existing leases, and projects already receiving assistance: The new rule would not apply to leases entered into before the law takes effect or to a developer that received city financial assistance before then.
  • Other renters: The bill does not apply to every rental building. It covers certain projects built as multiple dwellings under a government regulatory agreement, and excludes specified types of housing, including municipal housing authority-owned buildings.
  • City agencies: The Department of Housing Preservation and Development is named in the bill, but the text does not assign it a specific enforcement or administration duty.

The Council’s summary says current law makes pet-restrictive covenants invalid only after a pet has been kept openly and notoriously for three continuous months. The existing law’s text was not supplied, so I could not verify that description against the current Administrative Code.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets no fee, fine, appropriation, or cost estimate.
  • Developers may face costs from changing lease terms or handling disputes, but the materials do not estimate them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out a complaint, enforcement, or appeal process, or say who would enforce the new rule.
  • It does not explain how tenants or developers would determine whether a project meets the coverage requirements.
  • The bill’s definition of “pet” refers to animals normally kept in or near a household without further defining that phrase.
  • The materials do not explain how the bill would interact with other pet-related rules or existing agreements.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a pet ban in a publicly assisted rental project may be an unnecessary barrier for tenants who have pets.
  • The bill would make the rule apply to covered leases without requiring a tenant to keep a pet openly for three months first, as described in the Council’s summary.
  • The exception for damage, nuisance, or substantial interference would preserve a way to address serious problems caused by a pet.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill’s coverage depends on project and assistance definitions, while the text does not provide a process for resolving disputes about whether a building is covered.
  • The bill does not specify how the rule would be enforced or what a tenant could do if a developer or agent continued to enforce a pet ban.
  • The bill allows a developer or agent to bring an eviction or possession case based on listed harms, but does not explain how those terms would be applied.