Abolishing the criminal group database and prohibiting the establishment of a successor database

Summary#

Int. 0460-2026, sponsored by Council Member Althea V. Stevens, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code to abolish the Police Department’s criminal group database and bar any agency from creating a successor with the same or substantially similar features. Its stated aim is to end that database; the bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • The Police Commissioner would have to stop employees from using the database except to carry out the law or respond to records-access requests, transfer its records to the Police Department Inspector General, and destroy its information within two years.
  • Within 180 days, the Inspector General would have to notify by mail everyone whose name is or has been included, and run a public awareness campaign about the database’s abolition and access requests.
  • The Inspector General would enforce the law and report each year to the Mayor and Council Speaker.
  • Any agency would be barred from establishing a successor database with the same or substantially similar features. The Commissioner would have to ask federal and state agencies to destroy information they received, but the bill does not require those agencies to do so.
  • Employees who improperly access or use the database would face civil penalties of at least $500 for a first violation and at least $1,000 for later violations. An aggrieved person could also sue an employee for damages or other relief.

What it means for you#

  • People named in the database: The Inspector General would have to notify you by mail within 180 days and explain how to request records under New York State’s freedom of information law.
  • Police Department employees: After records are transferred to the Inspector General, department employees could not access them. Before abolition, access or use would be limited to carrying out the law or processing a records-access request.
  • Other city agencies: They could not establish a successor database with the same or substantially similar features.
  • People who believe an employee violated the law: You could sue that employee for relief, including damages, if you are aggrieved by the violation.

Money#

No cost estimate or funding source is provided in the available material.

  • The bill requires staff time for notices, the public awareness campaign, enforcement, and annual reporting, but gives no staffing or cost figures.
  • It sets minimum civil penalties for employees; it does not say how those penalties would be collected or where the money would go.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what counts as a successor database with “substantially similar features.”
  • It does not explain how civil penalties would be assessed or what process employees could use to challenge them.
  • It requires records to be transferred to the Inspector General and information in the database to be destroyed within two years, but does not clearly explain how those records would be handled or destroyed.
  • Federal and state agencies would only be asked to destroy information they received; the bill does not require them to comply.
  • The current Administrative Code text and the Police Department policy describing the database were not supplied, so the existing rules and practices could not be checked against the bill.

Case for#

  • A possible case for the bill’s design is that it would end the database and prevent another agency from creating a substantially similar one.
  • The bill requires notice to people named in it and gives them a way to request records before the information is destroyed.
  • Limiting access while the database is being wound down, and requiring Inspector General oversight and yearly reports, could help prevent further use during that period.

Case against#

  • One concern is that banning a successor database with substantially similar features could limit agencies’ ability to use that kind of criminal-group intelligence tool; the bill does not explain what alternative, if any, would be available.
  • The bill does not define “substantially similar,” which could leave uncertainty about which future systems are prohibited.
  • The bill imposes notice, campaign, oversight, and reporting duties without specifying their costs, staffing, or funding.