Summary#
Introduction 714, sponsored by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would require the Police Department (NYPD) to send the Council an annual report on certain paid police services to private entities; the bill’s stated goal is not provided. It is waiting in committee and is not law.
- The report would cover services in the preceding year, organized by month, provided by any off-duty department member for a fee payable to the NYPD. It must include services by the Paid Detail Unit or a similar or successor unit.
- The report must give the number and types of private entities served; list those entities unless disclosure could compromise public or officer safety or law enforcement operations; report department administration costs, if any; count personnel by rank; and state revenue, if any.
- “Police services” means specified crime prevention, law enforcement, public order, or protection work by an off-duty uniformed or plain-clothes member on behalf of a private entity. A private entity is any entity that is not a unit of government.
- If enacted, the local law would take effect immediately.
What it means for you#
- NYPD: Must prepare and submit the annual report. The bill does not require the department to provide services to any entity.
- Private entities: The bill does not change fees or eligibility for police services. Some entities’ names may be withheld under the safety and law-enforcement exception.
- Council and public: Would receive information on reported paid services, personnel, costs, and revenue. The bill does not require the report to be public.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The bill requires NYPD reporting but does not state the cost of preparing reports.
- It requires reporting any service-administration costs and revenue; it does not set fees or appropriate money.
What is unclear#
- The current Administrative Code was not supplied, so existing NYPD reporting duties cannot be verified. No publicly available information.
- The bill does not set criteria or a review process for deciding when naming an entity could compromise safety or operations.
- It does not state when each annual report is due.
Case for#
- The bill’s reporting requirements would give the Council month-by-month information about which types of private entities receive paid services, the personnel involved, department costs, and revenue.
- Reporting includes services by the Paid Detail Unit and similar or successor units, rather than being limited to one named unit.
Case against#
- The bill does not estimate the staff time or cost NYPD would need to prepare the reports.
- The exception could leave some entity names out, and the bill does not specify how those omissions would be explained or reviewed.