Reporting and analysis of pay and employment equity data concerning city contractors

Summary#

Int. 744-2026, sponsored by Council Member Farah N. Louis, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. It would add annual pay and employment data reporting by businesses that contract with covered city agencies, alongside the city-employee reporting system already in the text. Its stated goal is to help identify potential pay, employment, and retention disparities; the bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • City contractors would have to send the Department of Citywide Administrative Services (DCAS) annual information about current and former employees, to the extent it is available. The data list includes pay, job and demographic information, leave, overtime, benefits, and a unique identifier.
  • DCAS would have to send contractor data to the Mayor’s Office of Data Analytics (MODA) within 90 days of receiving it. MODA would have to report aggregated data by contractor, pay band, racial group, ethnicity, gender, and employment status.
  • MODA and DCAS would have to analyze contractor data annually, comparing it with prior years to identify potential disparities in pay, employment rates, and retention rates based on gender, race, or other protected classes under the City Human Rights Law.
  • DCAS could set different pay bands by rule with MODA. Reports must be formatted to prevent disclosure of employees’ racial group, ethnicity, and gender; DCAS’s website report must also prevent employees’ identities from being disclosed.

What it means for you#

  • City contractors: Each covered contractor would have to report the listed information for current and former employees no later than one year after the law takes effect, and annually after that. The definition covers businesses of many forms that contract with a covered agency.
  • Contractor employees: Their employment information would be collected by the city. Public reports must be aggregated or anonymized as described above, but the bill does not set out broader data-security or access rules.
  • City agencies and staff: DCAS would collect and pass on contractor data; MODA would prepare reports and conduct analysis with DCAS. The bill’s definition of agency excludes agencies headed by boards or elected officials, among others.
  • Public: The bill does not create a new benefit, change wages, or require contractors to correct disparities. It requires reporting and analysis.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires annual reporting and analysis by contractors, DCAS, and MODA, but gives no cost estimate or staffing amount.
  • It does not set a fee or fine for contractors that fail to report.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify how missing data should be handled beyond requiring information “to the extent” it is available.
  • It does not explain enforcement, penalties, appeals, or how DCAS would make contractors comply.
  • It does not set out data-security rules for the detailed employee records sent to the city.
  • The timing is unclear: the contractor analysis is due 90 days after the second annual contractor report, but the analysis must also be included in the annual report.
  • It is unclear how DCAS and MODA would choose alternate pay bands or how detailed public reports could be while preventing disclosure.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that comparable yearly data could help the city identify disparities in contractor workforces that would otherwise be hard to see.
  • Comparing results across years could help show whether potential disparities in pay, employment, or retention are changing.
  • The bill requires public reports while directing that they be formatted to protect employees’ identities and demographic details.

Case against#

  • One concern is that contractors would have to gather and submit a broad set of sensitive employee information, including date of birth, demographics, leave, overtime, and benefits; the bill gives no cost estimate.
  • The bill requires reporting and analysis but does not specify enforcement or what action, if any, follows when potential disparities are identified.
  • The bill describes protections for public reports but does not explain safeguards for the detailed data collected by DCAS and MODA.