Sales of cooperative apartments

Summary#

Int. 0774-2026, sponsored by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, would add a new chapter to the New York City Administrative Code. It would require most cooperative corporations to explain certain apartment-sale denials; its stated purpose is to give prospective purchasers enough information to understand the denial and deter delays or evasion. The bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • For co-ops with 10 or more dwelling units, a corporation that denies a prospective purchaser must provide a detailed written statement within five business days.
  • The statement must give every reason, identify deficiencies and the source of negative information, report application totals for the previous three years, and include an officer’s sworn or affirmed certification.
  • A purchaser or seller may sue over non-compliance. A court may award statutory damages of $1,000 to $25,000, costs and reasonable legal fees, and, for willful non-compliance, punitive damages capped at twice the statutory damages.
  • The New York City Commission on Human Rights may investigate non-compliance and, if it finds a violation, may impose a civil penalty of $1,000 to $25,000.
  • The bill does not change the reasons a co-op may lawfully deny a sale, require it to approve a purchaser, or let a court order it to reconsider an application.

What it means for you#

  • Prospective purchasers: If a co-op with at least 10 units denies your application, it must explain why within five business days. The explanation must be specific enough to show what deficiencies you might address.
  • Prospective sellers: You may join or bring an action alleging that the co-op failed to meet the statement requirements. The bill does not give you a right to force approval of the sale.
  • Cooperative corporations: Those covered must provide the statement and three-year application figures, and arrange for an officer to certify them under penalties of perjury. The bill also limits what reasons the co-op and its representatives may introduce in certain proceedings if those reasons were not included in a compliant statement.
  • Everyone involved: The statement-law case does not decide whether the stated reasons are genuine or whether discrimination occurred. Those questions remain for a separate proceeding.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • Co-ops could face damages and legal costs if a court finds they failed to comply. The bill sets damages at $1,000 to $25,000 and allows capped punitive damages for willful non-compliance.
  • The Commission may investigate and may impose a $1,000-to-$25,000 civil penalty. The bill gives no estimate for agency staffing or other public costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out a form or detailed process for preparing and delivering statements, or for the Commission’s investigations.
  • It does not explain how the required three-year application counts would be verified.
  • No information is provided about expected public costs, staffing, or how often the new duties or enforcement powers might be used.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that purchasers would learn the specific reasons for a denial, including application deficiencies, rather than receive an unexplained decision.
  • Requiring application totals and a sworn certification could make it harder to conceal or delay the reasons for a denial.
  • The bill preserves co-ops’ lawful grounds for denying a sale, so it adds disclosure and accountability rules without requiring approval.

Case against#

  • One concern is that preparing a detailed statement, collecting three years of application figures, and obtaining a sworn certification could impose significant work on covered co-ops; the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • A co-op that does not provide a compliant statement could face damages, legal fees, penalties, and limits on what reasons it may later introduce in certain proceedings.
  • The bill does not specify statement forms or investigation procedures, leaving some practical details to be worked out.