Establishing a child care workforce grant and services program

Summary#

Int. No. 820, sponsored by Council Member Jennifer Gutiérrez, would amend the New York City Administrative Code to require an agency or office designated by the Mayor to run a child care workforce grant and services program. Its stated goal is to help people without child care experience complete education and other requirements for child care work. The bill has not become law; it is waiting in committee.

  • The designated agency or office must offer financial help—including loans, grants, in-kind services or materials, or a combination—to help eligible people complete qualifying education programs and required exams or background checks.
  • To qualify for that financial help, a person must agree to work in child care in New York City for at least five years after completing a qualifying education program.
  • The agency must identify available child care jobs and help eligible people apply to them, including at least 100 people per fiscal year.
  • The agency must provide child care services to program participants to help them attend a qualifying program or exam, and must conduct outreach to the public and students in city schools with grades 9 through 12.
  • The agency must start receiving and processing applications no later than six months after the law’s effective date. The law would take effect one year after it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking child care work: The program would offer financial help and connections to services. To receive financial help, you would have to agree to work in New York City child care for at least five years after completing a qualifying education program. The bill does not require anyone to take a job.
  • Program participants: The designated agency must provide child care services to help you attend a qualifying education program or required exam or background check. The bill does not specify what those services must be.
  • Child care employers: The bill would require the agency to help people apply for available jobs, but it does not require employers to hire them or change hiring rules.
  • The city: The Mayor must designate the agency or office that runs the program. The bill creates a program within city government, not a new independent agency.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The agency must provide financial benefits, which may include loans, grants, in-kind services or materials, or a combination. The bill gives no spending amount or loan terms.
  • The agency must also provide child care services, run outreach, and help at least 100 people per fiscal year apply for jobs. The bill gives no cost estimate for these duties.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what counts as having “experience” in child care or set detailed eligibility rules.
  • It does not set grant amounts, loan repayment terms, how recipients would be chosen, or how a person’s five-year work commitment would be enforced.
  • It does not say what child care services participants would receive, or how and when they would get them.
  • It does not explain how the program would coordinate with existing services or how it would be overseen.
  • The bill’s application deadline is six months after its effective date, but the law would not take effect until one year after it becomes law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that financial help and child care services could make it easier for people without child care experience to complete required training and exams.
  • Helping participants apply for jobs could connect training to available work. The five-year commitment ties financial help to working in New York City child care.
  • The requirement to help at least 100 people apply for jobs each fiscal year sets a minimum for that part of the program.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the five-year work commitment could deter people from accepting financial help, especially because the bill does not explain how the commitment would be enforced.
  • The bill leaves key program choices, including benefit amounts, loan terms, and eligibility rules, to the designated agency. It does not set a spending limit or provide a cost estimate.
  • It is unclear what child care services participants would receive or how the agency would ensure that enough services and job openings are available.