Requiring that notices of violation issued by the department of sanitation be accompanied by a photograph of the alleged violation

Summary#

Introduction 827, sponsored by Council Member Christopher Marte, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would require photos with certain Department of Sanitation (DSNY) violation notices and make retained copies of those notices prima facie evidence (evidence that supports the stated facts unless rebutted). The bill is waiting in committee; it is not law, and passage is uncertain.

  • DSNY agents would have to include a photo with notices charging a person with violating provisions of the relevant code title or rules, where feasible.
  • DSNY would have to file and retain a copy of each notice served. The copy would count as a record kept in the ordinary course of business and as prima facie evidence of the facts it contains.
  • The law would take effect 90 days after it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • People charged with a covered violation: If the bill becomes law, you would receive a photo with your notice when taking one is feasible. The bill does not change the violation itself or set a new fine.
  • DSNY: The department would have to retain copies of all notices served, including when a photo is not feasible.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires DSNY to file and retain notices, but gives no estimate of staffing, storage, or other costs.

What is unclear#

  • “Where feasible” is not defined, and the bill sets no rules for what a photo must show or how it must be taken.
  • The supplied material does not include the current code text, so I cannot verify what existing law already requires.
  • The bill gives no further process for handling a notice without a photo or a disputed photo.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a photo could help recipients understand what conduct DSNY alleges and assess the notice.
  • Keeping the notice and its photo together could preserve evidence of the alleged violation.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “where feasible” leaves unclear when DSNY may issue a notice without a photo.
  • The notice copy would be prima facie evidence of its stated facts, but the bill does not explain how that evidentiary rule would apply when a photo is missing or unclear.