Requiring an annual interagency cooling tower compliance review and increasing related enforcement

Summary#

Introduction 1044, sponsored by Council Member Kamillah Hanks, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. Its stated goal is to find buildings and construction sites that may not meet cooling tower registration or certification rules and increase enforcement. It is not law; it is in the Committee on Health.

  • The Department of Buildings (DOB) must make an annual list of buildings and construction sites for which it has records showing a cooling tower is present or planned.
  • By March 1, DOB—or the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH), if an agreement gives it responsibility for cooling tower registration and certification—must compare the list with registration and certification records.
  • DOB must issue notices of violation by March 15 to owners of sites identified as lacking registration or certification.
  • An owner or operator found in violation must disinfect the cooling tower. At a vacant building or construction site, they must immediately stop using it and keep it out of use until the relevant rule is met.
  • The bill provides exceptions to those disinfection and shutdown requirements if the owner or operator supplies specified proof or sworn, notarized statements to the satisfaction of both commissioners.

What it means for you#

  • Building and site owners or operators: If found in violation, you would have to disinfect the tower; at a vacant site, you would also have to stop using it immediately until the registration or certification rule is met. The bill does not specify the time allowed for disinfection.
  • Owners or operators claiming an exception: You would have to provide the documentation listed in the bill, such as a sworn statement that water has not been introduced and will not be introduced before registration, or proof that the site has no cooling tower. The commissioners must find the material satisfactory.
  • DOB and DOHMH: They would have annual deadlines for listing, checking records, and issuing notices. The bill does not directly change rules for the general public.
  • Current-law comparison: The supplied material does not include the existing Administrative Code sections, so I could not verify which registration, certification, penalties, or enforcement rules are already in place.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires annual agency work and enforcement but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Owners or operators required to disinfect a tower may face costs; no amount is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say who sets the “specified time” for disinfection or how long it is.
  • It does not set out a process for disputing a notice, contesting a finding of violation, or resolving disagreements over whether submitted proof is satisfactory.
  • The review depends on records DOB already possesses; the bill does not explain how sites missing from those records would be found.
  • The text refers to existing code sections and rules that were not supplied, so their requirements and how they interact with this bill are unclear.
  • The bill would take effect 120 days after it becomes law; whether or when it will become law is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to identify possible registration or certification gaps by comparing building records with existing cooling tower records each year.
  • Requiring DOB to send notices by a set date could make follow-up more regular.
  • Requiring disinfection, and stopping use at vacant sites until compliance, could address risks associated with cooling towers that have not met the cited requirements.

Case against#

  • A list based on records held by DOB may miss sites that do not appear in those records, while record mismatches could lead to notices for sites that are compliant.
  • The bill requires disinfection within a “specified time” but does not itself state that time, leaving an important part of the requirement unclear.
  • The bill requires owners to provide particular proof to the satisfaction of two commissioners but does not explain how that decision is made or challenged.
  • Annual reviews, notices, and enforcement could require agency resources, but the available material gives no cost estimate.