Requiring the department of buildings to submit a report on the racial, geographic, and socioeconomic disparities in the enforcement of building violations

Summary#

Introduction 1097-2026, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams, would create a local law requiring the Department of Buildings (DOB) to study and report on disparities in building-violation enforcement and related outcomes. Its stated goal is to identify disparities and recommend ways to address them. The bill is laid over in the Finance and Housing and Buildings committees; it is not law.

  • DOB’s commissioner must submit a report to the Mayor and Council Speaker within one year after the law takes effect.
  • The report must examine violations, penalties, compliance rates, tax-lien sales, property foreclosures, inspection rates, plan-approval timelines for correcting homeowner violations, and violations based on 311 complaints.
  • The study must use data covering at least the 10 years before the law takes effect. The report must break down information by property type, borough, community district, and race, where possible, and describe its method.
  • The Department of Finance must provide tax-lien and other relevant data. The Department of Housing Preservation and Development must provide foreclosure and other relevant data.
  • The report must include recommendations for policy or operational changes. The bill does not require the city to adopt those recommendations.

What it means for you#

  • Residents and property owners: The bill would not itself change inspections, violations, penalties, tax-lien sales, foreclosures, or how homeowners correct violations. It would require a city study of those matters.
  • DOB, Finance, and Housing Preservation and Development: DOB must conduct the study and produce the report; the other two departments must provide relevant data to DOB.
  • General public: The bill requires the report to go to the Mayor and Council Speaker. It does not set a public-release requirement in the text.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires DOB to conduct a study and prepare a report, and requires two other departments to provide data; it gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set rules for how the agencies must measure race, geography, or socioeconomic status, or explain what data would establish a cause for a disparity.
  • Some information may not be available for the required breakdowns; the bill requires breakdowns only “to the extent possible.”
  • The bill does not require public release of the report or set follow-up steps for its recommendations.
  • The bill takes effect immediately if enacted, but it has not passed and its passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill would bring several connected outcomes into one study, including violations, penalties, compliance, tax liens, and foreclosures.
  • A 10-year data period and breakdowns by community district, borough, property type, and race could help identify patterns that a less detailed report might miss.
  • The report must examine possible reasons for disparities and recommend policy or operational changes, not only list data.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires a wide-ranging study but does not set a method for measuring socioeconomic disparities or establishing their causes.
  • The bill requires recommendations but does not require the city to act on them, so the study alone would not change enforcement or related outcomes.
  • The bill assigns work to three departments but provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.