Eliminate court, probation, and parole surcharges and fees as well as prohibit mandatory minimum fines for penal and vehicle and traffic laws (S.00313/A.04183)

Summary#

Res. 0138-2026 is a New York City Council resolution, sponsored by Council Member Lincoln Restler, calling on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign S.00313/A.04183. It would not change city or state law or bind anyone. The stated goal is to support changes to court fines and fees; the resolution is waiting in committee.

  • The resolution asks the State to eliminate court, probation, and parole fees and surcharges, and prohibit mandatory minimum fines for Penal Law and Vehicle and Traffic Law offenses.
  • Its recitals also describe the state bills as ending incarceration for failure to pay fines, fees, or surcharges, and say the Council supports individual assessments of a person’s ability to pay.

What it means for you#

  • People facing or receiving fines in New York State: The resolution itself changes no fines, fees, payment rules, or penalties. It asks State lawmakers and the Governor to act.
  • New York State lawmakers and Governor: The Council is calling on them to pass and sign the named state bills. The state-bill text is not included, so its exact rules cannot be verified here.

Money#

The resolution itself does not appropriate money; no cost estimate is provided.

  • No publicly available information on the cost of implementing the state bills is included in the materials.

What is unclear#

  • The text of S.00313/A.04183 is not supplied, so the precise scope, exceptions, and start date of the proposed state-law changes are unclear.
  • The materials do not give an estimate of the state or local costs, or explain how any lost fee and surcharge revenue would be addressed.
  • The Council history shows referral to committee on January 29, 2026, but gives no committee name, hearing, or vote.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s sponsors argue that mandatory charges can apply regardless of a person’s ability to pay and can create serious financial burdens.
  • The resolution cites the Brennan Center, the NYC Bar Association, and a 2023 U.S. Department of Justice letter as raising concerns about the fairness, effects, or efficiency of fines and fees.
  • The resolution says the state bills would remove some charges and mandatory minimum fines, and describes ending incarceration for nonpayment as part of the proposed changes.

Case against#

  • The resolution provides no detailed case against the state bills. A concern is that, without their text or a cost estimate, the consequences of the proposed changes—including effects on government revenue—cannot be assessed from these materials.