Allowing local governments to cap rent for SCRIE and DRIE enrollees at one-third of their total annual household income (S.2451A/A.7729)

Summary#

Resolution 463, sponsored by Council Member Shahana K. Hanif, asks the New York State Legislature to pass S.2451A/A.7729 and the Governor to sign it. The state bill would allow local governments to cap rent for people enrolled in SCRIE or DRIE at one-third of their total annual household income; the goal stated in the resolution is to reduce rent burdens.

  • The resolution does not change New York City law or require the City to adopt a cap. It is a nonbinding request to state officials.
  • If the state bill became law and a local government chose to act, that government could cap rent for SCRIE and DRIE enrollees at the stated level.
  • The resolution says the current programs freeze an enrollee’s rent at the amount they paid when entering the program. It does not itself change that rent.

What it means for you#

  • SCRIE and DRIE enrollees: No rent changes under this resolution. Any cap would depend on state action and a local government choosing to use the authority.
  • New York City: The Council is asking state officials to act. The resolution does not require a City agency to administer a new cap or establish a new process.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution itself does not authorize spending or require the City to fund a rent cap.
  • The material does not say who would bear the cost if a cap reduced an enrollee’s rent payment.

What is unclear#

  • The text of S.2451A/A.7729 is not supplied, so its detailed rules and limits cannot be verified here.
  • It is unclear whether or how New York City would choose to use the authority.
  • The resolution does not explain how a cap would be calculated or who would cover any difference between capped rent and the amount otherwise owed.

Case for#

  • The resolution argues that freezing rent at an already high amount may not ease an enrollee’s burden. It cites LiveOn NY’s statement that older tenants may pay more than half their income in rent even while enrolled.
  • The resolution also cites the State Comptroller’s finding that, as of 2023, 60% of older New York City tenants spent at least 30% of gross income on rent. A cap could give local governments a way to address high rents for enrollees.

Case against#

  • A possible concern is that the resolution does not explain who would cover the cost when the cap lowers an enrollee’s rent payment.
  • The authority would be optional for local governments, so the resolution does not ensure that New York City would adopt a cap or that enrollees would receive a lower rent.