Anti-Racism Act would require strategy and reports

Summary#

Bill 114 is the Anti-Racism Act, 2017, enacted as Chapter 15 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It creates a new Act and continues the existing Anti-Racism Directorate; it also includes a conditional change to the definition of “public sector organization” if another bill receives Royal Assent. Its stated goal is to eliminate systemic racism and advance racial equity.

  • The Ontario government must maintain an anti-racism strategy, with initiatives, targets and indicators. It must review the strategy at least every five years and publish annual progress reports.
  • The Minister must establish data standards, with Cabinet approval. Regulations may require or allow specified public sector organizations to collect specified information, including personal information, for specified programs, services or functions.
  • The Act sets rules for using, protecting, retaining and disclosing personal information collected under those regulations. The Information and Privacy Commissioner may review practices and order changes or destruction of information.
  • The Minister must establish an anti-racism impact assessment framework, with Cabinet approval. Regulations may require public sector organizations to use all or part of it for specified policies and programs.
  • The existing Anti-Racism Directorate must assist the Minister. The Act allows employees to be appointed as needed; it does not create a separate independent organization.

What it means for you#

  • People asked to provide information: A program, service or benefit cannot be withheld because you refuse to provide information under the Act. Organizations must give notice about the collection and its purpose. The Act limits how information collected under its rules may be used and disclosed.
  • Public sector organizations: The Act covers, among others, ministries, municipalities, school boards, universities, colleges and certain publicly funded organizations. An organization must collect information or use the impact-assessment framework only if regulations require or authorize it for specified purposes.
  • Researchers: An organization may disclose personal information for research only under the Act’s conditions, including research ethics approval and a written agreement. A research ethics board cannot approve use of identifiable information if the research can reasonably be done without it.
  • Ontario government and affected communities: The government must review the strategy at least every five years and consult communities most adversely impacted by racism. This includes Indigenous, Black and Jewish communities and communities adversely impacted by Islamophobia.
  • People and organizations generally: The Act does not itself require every public body to collect personal information, apply the assessment framework to every policy, or provide a new front-line service. It does not reduce rights under the Human Rights Code.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Act’s estimated cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The Act allows employees to be appointed as needed for the Anti-Racism Directorate, but gives no staffing number or cost.
  • Public sector organizations may have costs if regulations require data collection or use of the assessment framework. No estimate is given.
  • A person who wilfully fails to comply with certain Information and Privacy Commissioner orders can face a fine of up to $100,000. This applies to orders to stop a practice or destroy personal information, not to every breach of the Act.

What is unclear#

  • The Act does not set out the detailed data standards or assessment framework. The Minister must establish them, but their contents are not included here.
  • Regulations will determine which organizations, information, programs and services are covered. The Act does not say when or how broadly those regulations will apply.
  • The Act does not define key terms such as “systemic racism,” “racial equity” or communities “most adversely impacted by racism.”
  • The Act requires progress reports but does not set a required result or say what happens if targets are missed.
  • The supplied material does not explain how the conditional change to the definition of “public sector organization” would interact with the other bill it names.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to make anti-racism work a continuing government duty, rather than relying only on a strategy that could change without a statutory review schedule.
  • Targets, indicators and progress reports could make it easier to track whether the strategy is being carried out.
  • Collecting and analyzing information about racial disparities could help identify where policies or services have unequal effects. The Act limits use of information and requires security measures.
  • The impact-assessment framework could prompt organizations to consider racial impacts when developing or changing policies and programs.

Case against#

  • A possible concern is that regulations could require collection of personal information across many types of public sector organization, while the Act does not itself specify the full scope of collection.
  • Safeguards limit some uses and disclosures, but collecting personal information still creates privacy risks and adds work for organizations.
  • The Act does not require the impact-assessment framework to apply to all public sector organizations or policies; that depends on later regulations.
  • The Act requires reports and targets but does not specify consequences if the strategy fails to meet them.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2017042601

    Passed85 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 114

    FOR · 85

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    85For

    • Liberal52
    • PC19
    • NDP14

    0Against