Policing Oversight Act

Summary#

Bill 175, the Safer Ontario Act, 2018, was enacted as Chapter 3 of Ontario’s 2018 statutes. It replaces the Police Services Act with a new one, creates policing oversight and discipline laws, and enacts laws on missing persons and forensic laboratories; it also amends the Coroners Act and other laws. Its stated goal is to change how policing, oversight and related services are organized and carried out—not to guarantee particular safety outcomes.

  • Police services and boards must provide “adequate and effective policing.” Regulations can allow other providers to perform some functions. For-profit providers are limited to crime prevention; listed investigative supports; explosives disposal where qualified technicians would not otherwise be reasonably available; and help for crime victims. The responsible police board or Commissioner remains accountable for meeting standards.
  • Municipal councils must adopt community safety and well-being plans. Plans must identify risk factors, priorities, strategies and measurable intended outcomes; councils must carry out actions the plans require and report on their effects.
  • The Act continues Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit and public police-complaints office under new laws, and creates an Inspector General and a discipline tribunal. The Inspector General can inspect compliance and, in specified cases, direct corrective action.
  • Police can seek court orders for records to locate a missing person, or make urgent demands without first getting an order when delay could risk serious harm or destruction of records. A justice may also authorize entry to premises to find the person.
  • Prescribed forensic tests requested for legal purposes can be conducted only by laboratories accredited to prescribed standards. The Coroners Act changes include requiring investigations into deaths in police custody or caused by police use of force.
  • The Act gives authorized court-security providers powers to request identification and information, search people and property, refuse entry and, in specified cases, arrest.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal residents and taxpayers: Your council must prepare and publish a community safety and well-being plan, consult specified groups and report on its effects. This is a planning duty, not a guarantee that new services will be created.
  • People reporting police conduct: Any eligible person may complain to the Policing Complaints Director. The Director must review each complaint and, subject to listed exceptions, investigate complaints about an officer’s or special constable’s conduct. If there are reasonable grounds to believe professional misconduct occurred, the matter must go to the discipline tribunal.
  • People missing or seeking to locate someone: Police may obtain records through a court order, or an urgent demand in the stated emergency circumstances. A court must weigh the public interest in locating the person against privacy interests and consider signs the person may not wish to be found, including leaving abuse. Once found, a person’s location generally cannot be shared to help others contact them without consent, subject to an incapacity exception.
  • People entering court premises: An authorized security provider may require identification and information and search a person, vehicle or property. Refusing can lead to refusal of entry, removal or arrest; related offences carry fines up to $25,000 for a first offence or $50,000 for later offences, or up to 60 days in jail, or both.
  • Forensic laboratories: The accreditation rule applies only to test categories and standards set by regulation, not automatically to every laboratory test.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Municipalities must provide sufficient funding for their police boards’ required policing and operating costs. Councils also pay a community safety planner’s remuneration and expenses if the Minister appoints one for repeated, intentional failures to meet certain planning duties.
  • Municipalities may be charged for OPP policing and extra policing costs, with payment rules set in regulations.
  • The material gives no estimates for staffing, oversight, inspections, laboratory accreditation or implementation costs.

What is unclear#

  • Many details depend on regulations, including policing standards, which outside providers may perform particular functions, forensic test categories and accreditation standards.
  • The material does not give the dates when all provisions took effect; some were to start by proclamation.
  • The Act sets out planning duties but does not specify a required level of spending on the strategies in a municipal plan.
  • The material does not provide cost estimates or explain how new duties would be staffed and funded.
  • The full parent Acts and regulations are not supplied, so the precise before-and-after legal position cannot be independently checked against all prior law. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make police oversight more structured, with complaint investigations, inspections, corrective directions and public reporting.
  • Requiring municipalities to identify local risks, consult communities and measure intended outcomes could help connect safety planning with services beyond policing.
  • Court-approved record orders and narrowly conditioned urgent demands could give police tools to locate missing people when time matters, while requiring consideration of privacy and the person’s wishes.
  • Accreditation rules could set quality standards for forensic tests used in legal matters.

Case against#

  • Urgent demands allow police to require records without prior approval from a justice. That may expose sensitive information; the bill provides for later reporting and notice, but notice can be delayed.
  • Plans must be prepared and acted on, but the bill does not set spending levels or guarantee the strategies will be funded or effective.
  • The bill leaves many important standards and operating details to future regulations, making the practical scope and cost difficult to judge from the text alone.
  • Court-security powers to demand information, search and arrest could affect privacy and access to court premises; the bill does not set out every practical limit in the supplied material.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2018030801

    Passed75 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 175

    FOR · 59AGAINST · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    59For

    • Liberal49
    • NDP10

    16Against

    • PC16
  2. Division No. 2018030602

    Passed91 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 175, An Act to implement measures with respect to policing, coroners and forensic laboratories and to enact, amend or repeal certain other statutes…

    FOR · 51AGAINST · 40

    51For

    • Liberal51

    40Against

    • PC24
    • NDP15
    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2017120502

    Passed88 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 175

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 39

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • Liberal48
    • Independent1

    39Against

    • PC26
    • NDP13
  4. Division No. 2017120503

    Passed88 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 175

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 39

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • Liberal48
    • Independent1

    39Against

    • PC26
    • NDP13