Poet Laureate Act Advances Arts Literacy

Summary#

Bill 186 would create a new Ontario law, the Poet Laureate of Ontario Act (In Memory of Gord Downie), 2017; it does not amend an existing Act. It would establish a Poet Laureate as an officer of the Legislative Assembly, with duties and a selection process set by the bill. Its stated aim is to promote arts and literacy, celebrate Ontario and its people, and raise the profile of Ontario poets.

  • The Minister of Tourism, Culture and Sport must set up a selection committee every two years, or more often if needed. The committee selects a candidate; the Lieutenant Governor in Council appoints that person on the Assembly’s address.
  • The selection committee includes two members of the Ontario Arts Council who know about literary activity in Ontario, plus the current Poet Laureate. If there is no current holder or that person is unavailable, the two members select a third committee member.
  • A candidate must have their primary residence in Ontario and have lived in Ontario for at least six months in the preceding year. They must also have published a poetry volume in the past 10 years or have a body of work that has brought honour to them and Ontario.
  • The Poet Laureate must carry out listed responsibilities and activities, including promoting art and literacy, raising awareness of poetry, visiting schools, and advising the Legislative Library about its collection. The term can be up to two years; the holder remains in office until a successor is appointed.

What it means for you#

  • Poets: An eligible poet could be selected, but the bill does not create an application process or give anyone a right to the office.
  • The Poet Laureate: The office holder must carry out the bill’s responsibilities. Some activities have conditions: poetry for use in the Legislature is only required occasionally if the Speaker or Lieutenant Governor calls for it. Other duties may be requested by the Speaker, Lieutenant Governor or Legislative Library.
  • The ministry and Assembly: The minister must establish the selection committee and may pay an honorarium or reimburse approved expenses. Appointment is made by the Lieutenant Governor in Council on the Assembly’s address. The Lieutenant Governor in Council may remove the holder for cause, also on the Assembly’s address.
  • The public: The bill creates an office, not a new independent agency or a guaranteed service for every school or community. It does not directly change taxes, benefits, or property rights.

Money#

The bill allows an honorarium and expense payments, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The minister may pay an honorarium; the bill does not set an amount.
  • The minister may reimburse travel within Ontario and other expenses related to the Act, but expenses must be approved in advance.
  • The bill requires the minister to establish a selection committee but does not state its staffing or operating costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how candidates are put forward, how the committee chooses among them, or how the appointment process works in practice.
  • “A body of work” that has “brought honour” to the poet and Ontario is not defined. The bill also does not define “for cause” as grounds for removal.
  • The bill gives no honorarium amount, spending limit, or budget.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give poetry and literacy a visible role in public life and to celebrate Ontario’s culture.
  • A Poet Laureate could connect the Legislature, schools, the Legislative Library and the public through readings, writing and other listed activities.
  • The selection committee includes people with literary knowledge and, when available, the current Poet Laureate.

Case against#

  • The bill requires broad responsibilities but does not set measures for judging whether they have been carried out or how much activity is expected.
  • The selection criteria include an undefined standard about bringing honour to Ontario, and the bill gives few details about how candidates are considered.
  • The minister may pay an honorarium and expenses, but there is no cost estimate or spending limit in the bill.