Summary#
Bill 20, the Improving Mental Health and Addictions Services in Ontario Act, 2016, would continue an existing advisory council and amend the Ombudsman Act. Its stated goal is to improve the coordination and delivery of mental health and addictions services across Ontario.
- The Council would advise on and monitor implementation of recommendations made by a 2010 legislative committee. It would have up to 19 members, appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council on the Minister’s recommendation.
- Within one year after the Act came into force, the Council would have to give the Minister a plan. The plan must cover a proposed province-wide umbrella organization, consolidation of programs and services in the Ministry, service gaps and standards, and a proposed budget.
- The proposed organization, Mental Health and Addictions Ontario, would be in the plan; this bill would not itself establish it or require the government to adopt the plan.
- The Council could recommend ways to improve services, including reducing mental illness, addictions and stigma. It would have to report annually, and the Minister would have to table and publish its report.
- The Ombudsman could use the powers available under the Ombudsman Act in relation to providers of mental health and addictions services in Ontario.
What it means for you#
- People using mental health or addictions services: The bill would not directly change your access to services, create a new benefit, or guarantee that services will improve. It would require a plan addressing how services might be coordinated and gaps addressed.
- Service providers: The Ombudsman could use its powers under the Ombudsman Act in relation to providers. The bill does not set out a separate complaint or investigation process for them.
- Taxpayers: Council members may be paid and reimbursed for expenses. The bill gives no amounts.
- Government: The Council and Minister would have duties to prepare, publish and report on the plan and the Council’s work.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- Council members may be paid and reimbursed for expenses, at amounts determined by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
- The Council’s plan must include a proposed budget for the proposed umbrella organization. The bill does not fund that organization or specify a spending amount.
- The bill does not estimate the cost of the Council’s work or Ombudsman investigations.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define which organizations or people count as providers of mental health and addictions services.
- It does not require the government to establish Mental Health and Addictions Ontario, accept the Council’s plan, or carry out its recommendations.
- It does not set out how the Council would gather information for its inventory and analysis, or how providers or service users would take part.
- The supplied material does not include the Ombudsman Act or the law defining local health integration networks. I could not verify the Ombudsman’s current powers or the exact geographic boundaries the bill refers to.
Case for#
- A province-wide plan, inventory and analysis could help identify gaps, duplicated services and differences between areas.
- A single organization could be considered a way to coordinate services across the province, if the government later establishes it.
- Ombudsman investigations could provide an additional way to examine concerns involving service providers.
Case against#
- The bill requires a plan, not the creation of the proposed organization or delivery of the plan’s recommendations. Better coordination and services are therefore not guaranteed.
- The proposed organization’s powers, governance, accountability and budget are left for the plan to recommend.
- The Ombudsman provision covers providers broadly but does not define who qualifies or explain how the existing Ombudsman process would apply to them.