Summary#
The Protecting Students Act, 2016 amends the Early Childhood Educators Act, 2007 and the Ontario College of Teachers Act, 1996. Its stated goal is to strengthen rules for professional conduct and complaints involving early childhood educators and teachers.
- The Ontario College of Teachers must revoke a teacher’s certificate for specified serious sexual abuse of a student or an offence involving child pornography. Some other orders to suspend or revoke a certificate take effect even if appealed.
- The Act changes how complaints are handled, adds optional complaint-resolution processes for some cases, and sets a “best efforts” 120-day target for disposing of complaints at the investigation stage.
- Employers must report certain misconduct-related employment actions and other specified matters to the College, and share reports and follow-up information with the member.
- The College must publish specified discipline decisions and resolutions, including the member’s name, subject to limits such as orders protecting identities.
- Early childhood educators whose certificates have expired or been revoked, suspended or cancelled remain under the College’s jurisdiction for certain conduct from the period when they held a certificate or it was suspended. The Act also allows committees to use panels that may include eligible people from a roster.
What it means for you#
- Teachers: Some kinds of sexual abuse of a student and prohibited acts involving child pornography require certificate revocation. For specified sexual abuse, sexual misconduct or child-pornography cases resulting in revocation, the person cannot apply for a new certificate for at least five years.
- Students and the public: The College must publish specified discipline decisions and resolutions. A designated person or body must report suspected risk of physical or emotional harm by a member when it has reasonable grounds and believes urgent disclosure is needed.
- Teachers and complainants: For eligible cases, the College and member may agree to try resolving a complaint without the usual investigation or discipline process. These processes cannot be used for allegations of sexual abuse of a student, sexual misconduct or prohibited acts involving child pornography. The complainant is not a party to the resolution process.
- Employers: They must make specified reports, generally within 30 days, and give the member a copy. If there are reasonable grounds to believe urgent intervention is needed to prevent continued sexual abuse or likely harm to a student, the report must be made immediately.
- Early childhood educators: A member may apply to have certain registration terms or limits removed or changed, subject to a fee and possible waiting periods. This is an application process, not an automatic change.
- Taxpayers and the public: The Act changes the powers and duties of existing colleges; it does not create a new college or a general front-line student service.
Money#
The Act creates College and employer duties, but no cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- A fee is required for an early childhood educator’s application to change registration conditions; the amount is set by College by-laws.
- No budget figure is provided for staffing, administration, complaint handling or publishing information.
What is unclear#
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so the full pre-existing rules—and the exact change from current law in every area—could not be checked.
- Many details depend on future regulations or College by-laws, including complaint-process rules, some reporting and register rules, and fees.
- The Act sets a 120-day “best efforts” target for investigation-stage complaints, but does not guarantee that every complaint will be resolved within that time.
- Regulations determine which people or bodies have the urgent duty to report suspected risk of harm.
Case for#
- The Act appears intended to improve student protection through employer reporting duties, urgent reporting, emergency investigation powers and immediate effect for some orders.
- Mandatory revocation for specified severe conduct sets a clear consequence for those cases.
- Public access to discipline decisions may help people check a teacher’s professional record, while the Act also limits personal health information and allows orders to protect identities.
- Complaint resolution may offer a way to resolve some less serious cases without a full investigation or discipline hearing.
Case against#
- Some important rules are left to future regulations and College by-laws, so the Act itself does not settle all details of how the processes will work.
- In complaint-resolution processes, complainants are not parties. At the discipline stage, there is no right to appeal the committee’s decision on a proposed resolution.
- Publishing members’ names and discipline information may raise privacy concerns, even though the Act provides limits and protections.
- The Act adds reporting, investigation and publication duties, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate for carrying them out.