Remembrance Week Act Establishes Two-Minute Silence

Summary#

Bill 55, Remembrance Week Act, 2016, was enacted as a new law and repealed the Remembrance Day Observance Act, 1997. Its stated goal is to proclaim the week before Remembrance Day as Remembrance Week and honour those who died serving Canada.

  • Each year, November 5 through November 11 is proclaimed Remembrance Week.
  • At 11 a.m. on Remembrance Day, the people of Ontario are told to observe two minutes of silence. The Act says this can only be achieved through voluntary observance.
  • The Act lists ways to promote the silence, such as holding services or assemblies and briefly stopping assembly lines. These are suggestions, not requirements.
  • The Act does not set a penalty or enforcement process for not observing the silence.

What it means for you#

  • People in Ontario: The Act calls on you to pause for two minutes at 11 a.m. on Remembrance Day. It also says observance is voluntary.
  • Businesses, institutions, schools and places of worship: The Act suggests ways you can mark the silence, but does not require you to use any of them.
  • General public: The Act does not establish Remembrance Day as a day off, require businesses to close, or create a new service or benefit.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied material gives no cost estimate, spending amount, staffing requirement, fee or revenue change.

What is unclear#

  • The Act says people “shall” pause, but also says the silence can only be achieved through voluntary observance. It does not explain the legal effect of those two provisions together.
  • The Act does not specify how the observance should be promoted or how the suggestions would be carried out.
  • The supplied material says the new Act expands the scope of the 1997 Act, but does not provide the earlier Act’s text to verify what requirements it contained.

Case for#

  • The Act sets a clear annual period for Remembrance Week: November 5 to 11.
  • A province-wide two-minute silence could give people and institutions a shared way to remember those who died serving Canada.
  • The listed activities are suggestions, leaving people and institutions to choose how they take part.

Case against#

  • The mix of “shall” and voluntary observance leaves uncertainty about whether the pause is a legal duty or a request.
  • The Act gives no process for promoting or supporting observance, so the practical effect depends on voluntary action.
  • The Act does not explain how its observance provisions compare with the requirements of the repealed 1997 Act.