Summary#
Bill 1, An Act to perpetuate an ancient parliamentary right, would make a formal assertion about the Ontario Legislative Assembly’s right to sit and act without leave from the Crown. It does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to record the constitutional importance of introducing a first, pro forma bill before considering the Throne Speech.
- The bill asserts the Assembly’s right to give precedence to matters other than those expressed by the Sovereign.
- It adopts the practice of introducing a pro forma bill to explain and record the importance of that first bill.
- It describes the practice as dating back to at least 1558 and as having been recorded by a House of Commons resolution in 1604.
- The bill creates no new office, program, tax, fee, benefit, penalty, or enforcement power.
What it means for you#
- Members of the Legislative Assembly: The bill would formally record the Assembly’s assertion that it can sit and act without leave from the Crown, and give precedence to other matters before considering the Throne Speech.
- Ontario residents: The bill does not directly change your rights, services, taxes, or duties. It concerns the Assembly’s parliamentary practice.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not authorize spending or require staffing in its text.
- No publicly available information on implementation costs is supplied.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not explain whether its assertion would change the Assembly’s legal position or mainly record an existing practice.
- It sets out no enforcement mechanism or process for resolving a dispute about the asserted right.
- It does not say whether introducing a pro forma bill would be required before every Throne Speech in future.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to affirm the Assembly’s ability to sit and act without first seeking leave from the Crown.
- Recording the practice in a bill could make its stated constitutional purpose clear.
- The bill ties that assertion to the Assembly’s ability to give priority to matters beyond those expressed in the Throne Speech.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain what legal effect its assertion would have beyond recording it.
- It gives no process for applying or enforcing the asserted right, so its practical effect is unclear.
- A possible concern is that the bill may record a parliamentary practice without materially changing how the Assembly operates.