Summary#
Bill 160, Education Amendment Act (Use of Seclusion and Physical Restraints), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Education Act. Its stated goal is to require the Minister of Education to set policies and guidelines on seclusion and physical restraints in schools.
- The Minister must set criteria that must be met before seclusion or physical restraints can be authorized.
- The policies and guidelines must require written notice to parents or guardians when a pupil is subjected to either practice.
- They must also require reporting to the Minister on their use in schools.
- The bill defines seclusion and physical restraints, but does not itself ban them. It would start on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Minister of Education: Must establish the policies and guidelines. The bill does not set the criteria itself.
- Pupils and their parents or guardians: The policies must require written notice to parents or guardians when a pupil is subjected to seclusion or physical restraints.
- Schools: The policies must include mandatory reporting to the Minister. The bill does not say who must submit reports or set out the reporting process.
- Current law: The bill amends the Education Act, but the supplied material does not include the Act. I cannot verify what rules or policies already apply.
Money#
No publicly available information. The supplied material includes no cost estimate.
- The bill requires the Minister to establish policies and guidelines, but does not say what staff or other resources would be needed or what they would cost.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not specify the criteria for authorizing seclusion or physical restraints, or when the Minister must establish the policies.
- It does not say who in a school must notify parents or report to the Minister, or how quickly they must do so.
- It does not require public release of reports, or set out oversight, complaints, or review processes.
- The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law. No publicly available information.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that required criteria could make clear when seclusion or physical restraints may be authorized.
- Required written notice could help parents and guardians learn when these practices are used on their child.
- Mandatory reporting to the Minister could provide information on how often the practices are used.
Case against#
- The bill leaves the authorization criteria to policies the Minister must establish, without setting limits or standards in the Act itself.
- It does not specify who must report, what information reports must contain, or whether the information will be made public.
- A possible trade-off is that the bill requires reporting and notice, but does not itself create a complaint or review process for pupils and families.