Cadet Community Service Award Bill

Summary#

Bill 220, the Murray Whetung Community Service Award Act, 2020, would create a new Ontario law. It would require the Minister of Heritage, Sport, Tourism and Culture Industries to provide for an annual award in each local Air, Army and Sea Cadet corps, for a cadet chosen by that corps. The stated goal is to recognize exceptional citizenship and volunteerism in the cadet’s community and corps, in a bill that honours veteran Murray Whetung.

  • Each local corps of the three named cadet organizations would have an award recipient each year.
  • The cadet’s own corps would select the recipient.
  • The Act would begin on a date set by proclamation; the bill does not give a date.

What it means for you#

  • Cadets: A cadet chosen by their corps for exceptional citizenship and volunteerism in the community and corps would receive the award. The bill does not set other eligibility rules.
  • Cadet corps: The recipient must be selected by the corps, but the bill does not set a selection process or explicitly require corps to make a selection.
  • Ontario government: The minister must provide for the awards. The bill does not say the minister must personally select recipients or administer each award.
  • First Nations communities: The preamble refers to First Nations veterans and Murray Whetung, but the award rules do not give First Nations cadets separate eligibility or selection criteria.
  • Everyone else: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or public services.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The minister would have to provide for awards each year, but the bill gives no budget, award value, or staffing estimate.

What is unclear#

  • What the award would consist of—such as a certificate, item, or money—is not stated.
  • “Exceptional citizenship and volunteerism” is not defined, and no selection criteria or review process is set out.
  • The bill does not explain how the minister would provide for awards or what role, if any, the minister would have after a corps selects a cadet.
  • The total number of awards and the date the Act would start are not specified in the bill.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would recognize cadets who serve their communities and corps, rather than limiting recognition to their cadet activities.
  • Having each local corps select its own recipient could allow the choice to reflect that corps’ knowledge of its cadets.
  • The bill connects the award to Murray Whetung’s community service, as described in its preamble.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires annual awards but does not say what they are or how they will be funded.
  • Without criteria or a selection process, it is unclear how corps would apply the standard of “exceptional” service consistently.
  • The bill does not clarify the minister’s role in putting the awards in place or what happens if a corps does not select a recipient.