Intimate Partner Violence Data-Sharing Bill Advances

Summary#

Bill 274, the Intimate Partner Violence Disclosure Act, 2021, would create a new Ontario law. It would let police services share prescribed information about intimate partner violence with eligible applicants or people police determine are at risk; its stated goal is to help protect people from intimate partner violence.

  • Police services may disclose information when the bill’s requirements are met; they are not required to make every disclosure.
  • A person may apply if they believe they are at risk or meet other criteria set by regulation. Police may also decide someone is at risk and disclose information without an application.
  • The Minister may collect, use and disclose personal information for purposes under the Act, including under information-sharing agreements with other governments.
  • The Minister must establish a training program for police and other government employees who come into contact with victims of domestic violence.
  • When police disclose information, they must provide information about gender-based violence support services. A police service may use specified support workers and health professionals as intermediaries.
  • Recipients generally may not use or disclose the information for unrelated purposes. The bill also limits use of application and disclosure information in family and child-protection proceedings.

What it means for you#

  • People who believe they are at risk: You could apply for prescribed information about an intimate partner or former partner, if you meet the requirements set by regulation. Someone else may apply for you in certain circumstances, including with your consent.
  • People police determine are at risk: Police could provide information even if you did not apply. The bill does not require police to do so in every case.
  • People receiving information: You generally could not use or share it for purposes unrelated to the Act without the other person’s consent or legal authority.
  • Police services and the Minister: They could collect, use and disclose personal information for the Act’s purposes. Police must give support-service information when they disclose information.
  • People whose information may be disclosed: The bill does not specify what information would be disclosed or set out a notice process for the person the information is about.
  • People who stay in a relationship: A government agency or office could not deny you services or protection because you received information and stayed in the relationship. Applying for, not applying for, receiving, or not acting on information could not be used against you in family or child-protection proceedings.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Minister must establish a training program, but the bill gives no estimate for its cost or staffing.
  • The bill does not specify funding for police services or support organizations, or set out fees or fines.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations would set key details, including what information may be disclosed, who qualifies, and the requirements police must follow. Those regulations are not included.
  • The bill does not set out application steps, decision timelines, reasons for decisions, an appeal process, or rules for correcting inaccurate information.
  • It does not specify how police should assess risk or how they should ensure disclosed information is accurate and current.
  • It does not explain how the Act would interact with existing police information-sharing practices. The source material does not include the other Acts named in the bill, so their current rules and definitions could not be checked.
  • The Act would start on a date set by proclamation; no start date is given.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that access to information about a partner’s history could help someone make safety decisions.
  • Police could share information with a person at risk even if that person has not applied.
  • Required information about support services could connect a recipient with help, including safety-planning support.
  • The protections against denying services to someone who stays in a relationship recognize that receiving information does not mean a person will or can leave.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves central decisions to future regulations, including what information can be disclosed and who qualifies.
  • Police may disclose information, so the bill does not ensure that every eligible person receives it.
  • The bill does not set out how police must check the information’s accuracy, explain a refusal, or handle a challenge to a decision.
  • Police and the Minister would have powers to collect, use and disclose personal information, but the bill gives few operational details about oversight or safeguards.
  • The Minister may direct the release of information that identifies an applicant, despite the general rule that the applicant’s identity is privileged.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2021041401

    Defeated49 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 274

    AGAINST · 34FOR · 15

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    34Against

    • PC34

    15For

    • NDP12
    • Liberal2
    • Green1