Summary#
Bill 59, the Caregiver Recognition Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to increase recognition and awareness of caregivers and their contributions. It would set out principles for caregivers, but it would not make those principles enforceable rights or duties.
- A “caregiver” would mean a family member, friend or person of choice who gives unpaid care to someone with care needs related to disability, a physical, neurological or mental condition, chronic illness, frailty or age.
- The principles say caregivers and their contributions should be respected and supported; that caregivers have needs of their own; and that they should be treated with dignity and have support for health, social, economic and community life, including employment or education where appropriate.
- The first Tuesday of April each year would be Caregiver Recognition Day.
- Ontario ministries and government agencies may take practical steps they consider advisable to promote the principles. Ministries and agencies responsible for caregiver supports may consider the principles when developing, implementing, providing or evaluating those supports.
- The Act would not require any particular support or create rights or duties that could be enforced in court. It also says a failure to comply would not invalidate or provide grounds to challenge a government action or decision.
What it means for you#
- Unpaid caregivers: The Act would recognize the role and needs of people who fit its definition. It would not give them a new enforceable right to services, financial help, employment protections or other benefits.
- Ministries and government agencies: They may promote the principles and may consider them in work on caregiver supports. The bill does not require them to change a policy or service.
- Other people and organizations: The bill does not directly change the duties of care recipients, private businesses or the public.
- Caregiver Recognition Day: The date would be proclaimed each year, but the bill does not require a particular event or activity.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost of the bill.
- The bill does not set out a budget, new benefit, fee or fine.
- It allows ministries and government agencies to take promotional steps, but does not require them to spend a specified amount or hire staff.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not say what promotional steps agencies might take or how they would decide whether to take them.
- It does not set rules for how the principles would affect particular caregiver services or decisions.
- It allows regulations to add entities to the definition of “government agency,” but no such entities are named in the bill.
- The Act would start on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not say when, or whether, that would occur.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would formally recognize unpaid caregivers’ social and economic contributions and their own needs.
- Setting out shared principles could give ministries and agencies a reference point when they choose how to develop or deliver caregiver supports.
- An annual recognition day could help raise awareness, though the bill does not require specific events or outcomes.
Case against#
- The principles are not enforceable, and agencies only may promote or consider them. The bill does not ensure that caregivers receive more or better support.
- It does not specify services, funding, timelines or a way for caregivers to ask for a decision based on the principles.
- The bill may create expectations of change without requiring government agencies to make any particular change or report on what they do.