Theology School Forms Non-Profit Corporation

Summary#

Bill PR16, the Canadian Chinese School of Theology Act, 2019, would create a corporation without share capital (a non-profit corporation) for the Canadian Chinese School of Theology. The bill’s stated goal is to advance post-secondary Christian theological education in Chinese and English. It gives the School’s Board of Governors control of its affairs and authority to grant listed credentials.

  • The Board would manage the School. It could set policies, start or end programs, and adopt Christian doctrine statements that Board members and faculty must follow.
  • The Board could grant the diplomas and degrees listed in the bill. It could grant other degrees only if the School is authorized to do so under the Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000.
  • The Board would have 9 to 17 members; at least 51 per cent must be Canadian citizens or permanent residents. Members would serve three-year terms and could serve no more than nine consecutive years.
  • The Board could set and collect tuition and other fees, borrow money, and acquire, hold, sell, lease or mortgage property.
  • The School would need an annual audit by a licensed auditor and would have to make the audited annual statement available for public inspection. Board meetings would normally be closed.
  • The bill says the School had been operating in affiliation with Tyndale University College and Seminary since 2006. It does not say that the School must end that affiliation.

What it means for you#

  • Students: The bill does not set admission rules, tuition amounts, or student rights. The Board could set tuition and establish or end programs.
  • Faculty: If the Board adopts Christian doctrine statements, faculty would have to follow them. The bill does not require the Board to adopt such statements.
  • Board members: They would manage the School and could not benefit personally from serving. The Board could decide whether to open a meeting or invite a non-member; meetings would otherwise be closed.
  • Public: You could inspect the audited annual statement. The Board would decide how to publish the School’s by-laws.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not create a government-funded program or require government funding.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of the bill’s public cost.

  • The bill requires an annual audit but does not say what it would cost or how it would be paid for.
  • The Board could collect tuition and other fees, borrow money, and receive gifts and other property. The bill does not set fee amounts or provide a funding estimate.
  • The bill does not appropriate government money.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set admission, tuition-setting, academic review, complaint, or appeal processes.
  • It does not define “Christian doctrine” or say how any doctrine statements would be chosen or changed.
  • It does not explain what authorization the School would need under the Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000 to grant degrees beyond those listed in this bill.
  • The bill does not say how the School’s new corporation would relate to the Association of Canadian Chinese Theological Education, which applied for the legislation.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give a theological school that the applicant says has operated since 2006 its own corporate structure and Board.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that naming specific degrees and diplomas in law would give the School clear authority to grant those credentials.
  • The Board’s authority over programs, fees, property and finances could let it make decisions for the School directly.

Case against#

  • The Board would control programs, fees and academic policies, while its meetings would normally be closed. The Act does not set out a public process for these decisions.
  • The Board could adopt doctrine statements that faculty must follow, but the bill does not define those statements or set a process for challenging them.
  • The bill does not provide details on tuition, student protections, or how the School’s finances and decisions would be overseen beyond an annual audit and public access to the audited statement.