Bill says mental health should not be criminalized

Summary#

Bill 196, the Justice for Soli Act (Stop Criminalizing Mental Health), 2024, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its goal is to align with the first recommendation of the inquest into Soleiman (Soli) Faqiri’s death. It requires the Government of Ontario to recognize that correctional facilities are not appropriate places for people experiencing a mental health crisis, and that mental illness requires health care and should not be criminalized.

  • The Government of Ontario would have a legal duty to recognize those statements.
  • The bill does not give a particular ministry, correctional facility or health-care provider specific duties beyond that recognition.
  • The Act would start on the day it receives Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People experiencing a mental health crisis: The bill states that correctional facilities are not appropriate environments for you. It does not create a new right to hospital care or set out how care must be provided.
  • People in the justice system: The bill does not directly change arrest, charge, detention or release rules.
  • Government and correctional facilities: The government must recognize the bill’s statements. The bill does not require a specific change to facility operations or create a process for moving someone to health care.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not specify funding, staffing, spending, savings or fees.

What is unclear#

  • What legal or practical effect “recognize” would have, and how the duty would be enforced.
  • What counts as a “mental health crisis”; the bill does not define the term.
  • Whether the government would have to change policies, provide services or report on its actions.
  • How the bill would affect decisions about keeping someone in a correctional facility or arranging health care.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s current status. It would only take effect if it receives Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it puts a clear principle into law: people experiencing a mental health crisis need health care, not a correctional environment.
  • The bill appears intended to respond to the inquest’s first recommendation following Faqiri’s death.
  • A formal duty to recognize that principle could guide government policy, though the bill does not specify what changes would follow.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not require any specific service, operational change or action to move people from correctional facilities to health care.
  • It does not set out who is responsible for acting on the recognition duty, how compliance would be checked or what happens if the duty is not met.
  • It is unclear whether the bill would change what happens to people in a mental health crisis in practice.