Safer Municipalities Act would curb public drug use

Summary#

Bill 242, the Safer Municipalities Act, 2024, would create a new law and amend Ontario’s Trespass to Property Act. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, is safer municipalities; its main measures are restricting public consumption of illegal substances and adding sentencing factors for trespass. If passed, the new law would take effect on Royal Assent.

  • Police officers and provincial offences officers prescribed by regulation could direct someone they reasonably believe is consuming an illegal substance in public to stop, leave the place or part of it, or both. The person must promptly comply.
  • Failing to comply with a direction, or with a related direction to provide identifying information, would be an offence. The maximum penalty would be a $10,000 fine, six months in jail, or both.
  • Officers could arrest without a warrant someone they reasonably believe committed an offence under the new Act. They could also seize and destroy substances found in plain view and near that person if they reasonably believe the substances are illegal.
  • The ban would have exceptions, including supervised consumption sites and people authorized to possess the substance. The bill also protects people seeking emergency services from being charged or convicted when the evidence comes from seeking or staying for those services.
  • For trespass, courts would have to consider two aggravating factors when setting a penalty: being on premises more than 24 hours after notice to leave (or after a longer period given in the notice), and a court finding that the person is likely to trespass in the future. The bill does not create a new trespass offence or raise the existing maximum fine described in the bill materials.

What it means for you#

  • People consuming illegal substances in public: The bill would prohibit this, subject to its exceptions. The prohibition itself does not set out a separate penalty; the listed offences are failing to follow an officer’s direction or failing to provide identifying information when directed.
  • People seeking or providing emergency help: The bill provides protection from a charge or conviction in the specified circumstances. It also says the exemption applies to people who stay at the scene to help someone or receive emergency services.
  • Police and prescribed provincial offences officers: They could give directions, require identifying information in specified circumstances, arrest without a warrant, and seize and destroy substances found in plain view near the person. These are powers, not duties to act in every case.
  • People accused of trespass: A court would have to consider the new aggravating factors when setting a penalty. The bill does not require a higher penalty in every case.
  • Municipalities and the public: The bill does not directly create a new municipal service, treatment program, or housing benefit. It creates enforcement powers and allows regulations for possible escorted referrals to places providing listed services.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or set fees.
  • Enforcement and substance analysis could require resources, but the bill gives no cost estimate or staffing level.
  • The bill allows regulations to authorize taking a person into custody and escorting them to a service location instead of starting a proceeding; it does not itself fund or require that service.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations may define which places count as public, prescribe officers and exemptions, and set conditions or time limits for directions and seizures. Those rules are not included here.
  • The bill does not set out a required process for deciding whether to give a direction, how to handle a seized substance, or how an escorted referral would work.
  • The term “illegal substance” depends on whether possession is prohibited under federal law; the bill does not list substances.
  • The Trespass to Property Act itself was not supplied, so its current provisions and the bill’s changes could not be independently checked against the full Act. The bill materials say the existing trespass maximum fine is $10,000.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s passage status. It would not take effect unless passed and given Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives officers a way to respond when they reasonably believe someone is consuming illegal substances in a public place.
  • The exceptions for supervised consumption sites and specified emergency situations recognize that the prohibition should not apply in every circumstance.
  • Requiring courts to consider repeat trespass circumstances could help them account for notice to leave and the likelihood of future trespass when setting a penalty.

Case against#

  • The bill gives officers substantial powers, including arrest without a warrant and seizure and destruction of substances, while leaving key rules to future regulations.
  • The bill does not require officers to connect someone with health, housing, or addiction services. The option to escort someone to a service location depends on future regulations.
  • A court’s finding that a person is likely to trespass in the future is a broad factor to consider, and the bill does not explain how that likelihood should be assessed.