Summary#
Bill 76, the Respecting Workers in Health Care and in Related Fields Act, 2023, would create a new Ontario law. It would require the Minister of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development (or another minister assigned responsibility) to take all necessary steps to secure the employment standards listed below, including introducing more legislation if needed. The stated goal is to improve working conditions and encourage workers to stay in, or enter, these fields.
- Hospitals, long-term care homes, home care agencies and health care providers with more than 20 employees would have to reach a target of at least 70 per cent permanent, full-time employment.
- Personal support workers (PSWs) would be entitled to at least $8 an hour above minimum wage, paid sick leave, health benefits and pension-plan membership.
- Full-time PSWs would be entitled to at least 10 paid sick days per calendar year. Part-time PSWs would receive a number of days prorated according to hours worked.
- Homemakers employed by someone other than the householder to work in a private home would be entitled to at least minimum wage. The Minister would have to take steps to make rules on hours, eating and free time periods, and overtime pay apply to them.
What it means for you#
- Health care employers and providers: If they employ more than 20 people, the Minister would have to take steps to ensure at least 70 per cent of their workforce is permanent and full-time. “Health care provider” means a member of a regulated health professions college acting within their scope of practice.
- PSWs: The bill sets out the wage and benefit standards the Minister must work to ensure. It does not set out a system for claiming benefits or sick leave.
- Homemakers: The bill covers people hired by someone other than the householder to provide homemaking services in a private residence. It does not specify paid sick leave or benefits for them.
- Workers and employers: The bill does not itself set out detailed rules for enforcement, complaints or remedies. It requires the Minister to take all necessary steps, including bringing forward more legislation if needed.
- General public: The bill does not directly create a new front-line service or change taxes.
Money#
No publicly available information gives an estimate of the bill’s costs.
- The bill would require the Minister to take steps to bring about the stated employment standards, but gives no estimate of staffing or other government costs.
- Employers could face costs from higher wages, benefits, pension plans, paid leave, or changes to staffing. The bill provides no estimates.
What is unclear#
- “Personal support worker,” “full-time” and “part-time” are not defined in the bill. It also does not explain how to calculate a part-time worker’s prorated sick leave.
- The bill does not say how the 70 per cent target would be measured, or how permanent and full-time employment would be defined.
- It does not set deadlines for the Minister’s steps beyond saying the Act would start one year after Royal Assent.
- The bill does not explain how workers could enforce the proposed standards, or what penalties or remedies would apply.
- No publicly available information in the supplied material explains how these standards would interact with current employment rules.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address insecure work and low compensation in health care and related jobs.
- Setting wage, leave, benefit and pension standards could give workers clearer minimum protections.
- A permanent, full-time employment target could be seen as a way to encourage more stable jobs in larger health care workplaces.
Case against#
- The bill leaves important terms and implementation details open, including how to calculate the 70 per cent target and part-time sick leave.
- It requires the Minister to take “all necessary steps,” but does not say what those steps must be or when the standards must take effect in practice.
- The proposed wage and benefit standards could raise employer costs, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.