Attending-physician rules expanded for workers' comp

Summary#

HB 4119, titled “Relating to workers’ compensation,” would amend existing Oregon workers’ compensation laws; it would not create a separate program. Its stated goal is to prevent certified managed care plans from excluding willing providers and to broaden which providers can be attending physicians. The bill is listed as failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The Department of Consumer and Business Services director would have to certify a managed care plan only if it does not discriminate against or exclude a provider in its service area who is willing to meet the plan’s rules and terms.
  • The bill would change the “attending physician” definition to include nurse practitioners, physician associates, chiropractic physicians and naturopathic physicians as well as the providers already listed.
  • The bill’s redline removes limits of 60 days or 18 visits for chiropractors and naturopathic physicians, and 180 days for physician associates. The expanded definition would not apply in the same way to workers covered by managed care contracts; those contracts may designate providers or provider categories as attending physicians.
  • The bill would retain other managed-care certification requirements, including quality standards, review processes and dispute resolution.

What it means for you#

  • Injured workers: If the bill had become law, more types of providers could have been primarily responsible for treating a compensable injury without the time or visit limits shown in the existing wording. This would not guarantee that a particular provider could treat a worker under a managed care contract.
  • Providers: A certified managed care plan could not exclude a provider in its service area who is willing to meet all the plan’s rules and terms. The bill does not remove those conditions.
  • Managed care plans and the department: Plans would face a broader provider-participation requirement. The department director would apply it when deciding whether a plan qualifies for certification.
  • General public: The bill would change workers’ compensation rules, not create a general health-care benefit.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied materials. No publicly available information.

  • The bill does not state a new appropriation, fee, fine or staffing level in the text provided.
  • Plans might face costs related to provider participation, but the materials do not estimate them.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text ends partway through section 5, although it lists amendments to several other statutes. Those remaining changes cannot be assessed from the available text.
  • The current parent statutes were not supplied, so the full effect of the amendments against current law could not be verified. The bill’s redline does show the provider time and visit limits it would remove.
  • The text does not explain how a plan’s provider rules would be assessed when deciding whether excluding a willing provider is discrimination.
  • It is unclear how the new provider-participation requirement would interact with the removed requirement for an adequate number of providers in each category, which the redline shows would be deleted.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that workers could have more provider choices, because plans could not exclude a local provider willing to meet the plan’s terms.
  • Including more provider types in the attending-physician definition could let workers receive ongoing care from those providers without the time or visit limits shown in the existing wording.
  • The bill would retain quality, utilization-review and dispute-resolution requirements for managed care plans.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill removes the explicit requirement for an adequate number of providers in each category. A broader participation rule does not itself guarantee workers a sufficient choice or availability of providers.
  • The bill does not explain how the director would judge whether a plan’s rules are reasonable or whether an exclusion violates the new requirement.
  • Plans might have less flexibility to limit participation to selected providers, even though they must still meet quality and other certification standards. The practical effect and cost are not estimated.