Landlords could change smoking rules with notice

Summary#

HB 4120, titled “Relating to smoking policies in residential tenancies,” is enacted and amends Oregon laws on landlord rules and smoking-policy disclosures. It adds a limited exception to the existing rule that a landlord needs a tenant’s written consent to make a substantial change to the rental agreement. The bill’s stated goal is not set out separately; its title identifies smoking policies as its subject.

  • A landlord may change a smoking policy to prohibit smoking inside a dwelling unit or interior common areas without written tenant consent only if the bill’s conditions are met.
  • The affected unit must be in a development covered by a development agreement or share a wall with another unit, and it cannot be an “accessible unit” under the law cited.
  • The landlord must give at least 180 days’ written notice, provide and post at least one designated smoking area on the premises, and delay the change until the end of a fixed-term tenancy.
  • Rental agreements must continue to disclose whether smoking is prohibited, allowed throughout the premises, or allowed only in identified areas. The bill defines smoking as inhaling or possessing a lit tobacco product.
  • The disclosure rule does not apply to the specified rental agreements for space in a facility under ORS chapter 90.

What it means for you#

  • Landlords: For eligible units, you may make the specified indoor smoking-policy change without each tenant’s written consent, but only if you meet all the notice, designated-area, and timing conditions. Otherwise, the existing written-consent rule for a substantial change still applies.
  • Tenants: If your unit qualifies, a landlord may be able to prohibit smoking inside it or in interior common areas without your written consent. You must receive at least 180 days’ notice; if you have a fixed-term tenancy, the change cannot apply until that term ends.
  • Tenants and landlords: Rental agreements must state the premises’ smoking policy and identify any areas where smoking is allowed. The bill applies its amendments to rental agreements entered into before, on, or after its effective date.
  • People in accessible units: The new exception for changing a policy without written consent does not apply to an accessible unit as defined in the law cited. The bill does not otherwise describe what smoking rules apply to those units.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Landlords must provide and post a designated smoking area to use the new exception. The bill gives no estimate of the cost.
  • The bill does not provide public funding, staffing, fee, or fine amounts.

What is unclear#

  • The exact effective date is not provided, although the bill is listed as signed into law.
  • The bill does not explain how to determine whether a unit was developed under a qualifying development agreement or is an “accessible unit”; those terms refer to laws not included in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not set details for the designated smoking area, such as its location or how it must be maintained.
  • The bill does not set a process for disputes or explain enforcement or remedies for failing to meet its conditions.
  • The supplied text says in one place that the amendments are to ORS 90.260, while the section shown amends ORS 90.262. The available material does not resolve this mismatch. The full current statutes were also not supplied, so comparison is limited to the wording shown in the bill.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives landlords a way to prohibit smoking indoors without requiring written consent from every tenant, while keeping limits on when and how the change takes effect.
  • The 180-day notice and fixed-term protection give affected tenants time and prevent the change from taking effect during a fixed-term tenancy.
  • Requiring a posted smoking area means the change need not prohibit smoking everywhere on the premises.

Case against#

  • One concern is that eligible tenants could lose permission to smoke inside their unit or interior common areas without agreeing to the change.
  • The bill requires a smoking area but does not specify how suitable or accessible it must be, or how disagreements about it would be handled.
  • The exception applies only to specified types of units and excludes accessible units. The supplied text does not explain why those categories were chosen or how landlords should address different situations.
  • The bill does not provide a process for enforcing its conditions or resolving disputes.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1639460

    Passed53 members voted

    House Third Reading

    FOR · 51AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    51For

    • Democratic33
    • Republican18

    2Against

    • Democratic1
    • Republican1

    7 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1632569

    Passed13 members voted

    House Committee Do pass with amendments. (Printed A-Eng.)

    FOR · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    13For

    • Democratic7
    • Republican6

    0Against