Worship zoning limits county power

Summary#

Oregon SB 1560, “Relating to allowable uses of place of worship,” would amend ORS 215.441, an existing law about county zoning rules for places of worship. Its stated goal is to limit counties’ ability to regulate activities at those places. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Counties would still have to allow reasonable use of an eligible place of worship for listed customary activities, including worship, religious classes, weddings, funerals, meal programs and certain child care or early education.
  • The bill would remove counties’ express authority to impose reasonable rules about the physical characteristics of those uses, including site or design review.
  • A county could prohibit or restrict a use if it finds public facilities are inadequate, or if the use’s physical characteristics create a danger to occupants’ or the public’s health or safety.
  • The bill would not bar a county from allowing a private or parochial school for kindergarten through grade 12 or higher education where otherwise permitted.

What it means for you#

  • Places of worship: If the bill had become law, counties would have had less express authority to regulate the physical features of listed activities. The bill would not require every activity to be approved regardless of safety or public-facility limits.
  • Counties: A county could still prohibit or restrict a use on the stated grounds of inadequate public facilities or danger to health or safety. The bill would not set out a process for making those findings.
  • Schools: The bill would not require counties to allow private or parochial schools at places of worship. It says counties may allow them under otherwise applicable rules.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, these proposed changes did not take effect.

Money#

No cost information is in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full current version of ORS 215.441, so I could not independently verify the current law against the parent statute. The bill’s amendment markings show the wording it proposed to remove and replace.
  • The bill does not define “reasonable use,” “customarily associated,” “inadequate” public facilities or a “danger” to health or safety.
  • It does not specify how a county would make or document its findings, or what review or appeal process would apply.
  • The bill text provided does not state when it would start. In any case, the bill failed.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that listed activities at places of worship would face fewer county rules about physical features, making county restrictions more limited and explicit.
  • The bill would preserve county authority to restrict uses when public facilities are inadequate or when physical features create a health or safety danger.
  • Listing activities such as meal programs and child care could make clear that these uses are covered by the law’s allowance for reasonable use.

Case against#

  • One concern is that removing express authority for reasonable site or design review could limit counties’ ability to address physical impacts that do not amount to a danger to health or safety.
  • The bill does not define when facilities are “inadequate” or when a physical feature creates a “danger,” leaving important judgments to counties without stated decision rules.
  • The bill does not explain how its limits on county rules would interact with other applicable state and local requirements.