Scottish Local Government Elections (Candidacy Rights of Foreign Nationals) Bill

Summary#

This Government Bill amends the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973. Its stated goal is to give certain foreign nationals the right to stand in Scottish local elections in line with UK treaty agreements. The supplied status says it received Royal Assent, but the text provided is the introduced version, so I cannot verify whether the final law differs.

  • It adds qualifying nationals of Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal and Spain to the existing local-authority candidacy rules.
  • A person must also either not need UK immigration leave, or have (or be treated as having) some description of leave.
  • Scottish Ministers must add a country by regulations when the UK and that country intend to join a relevant treaty and the treaty has cleared the required UK parliamentary process to be ratified. Ministers may remove a country if it leaves a relevant treaty that the UK is also party to.
  • The new country-list regulations use the negative procedure (they take effect unless Parliament objects). The Act is to start the day after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Prospective candidates from the four listed countries: If you meet the immigration condition and the existing rules for nomination, election and holding office, the bill adds you to the groups eligible to stand. It does not remove other existing qualifications.
  • Other foreign nationals: The bill does not add you unless your country is later added to the list under the treaty rules.
  • Scottish Ministers: They must add countries when the stated treaty conditions are met, and may remove a country if it leaves the relevant treaty. The bill does not set an application or review process for candidates.
  • Voters: The bill changes who may be eligible to stand, but does not directly change who may vote.
  • Current law: The Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 was not supplied, so I cannot verify which foreign nationals could already stand or how the bill’s additions interact with every existing qualification.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill allows for ministerial regulations, but gives no estimate of their administrative cost or any staffing requirement.
  • It does not set a tax, fee, fine, benefit or dedicated fund.

What is unclear#

  • The introduced bill does not explain how the new eligibility rule interacts with every other qualification in the 1973 Act.
  • The supplied material does not include the Financial Memorandum, so the estimated public cost, if any, is unknown.
  • The bill does not explain how the treaty-based country list would be kept up to date in practice.
  • The removal power refers to a country leaving a treaty to which the UK is also party. The supplied text does not explain what happens if the UK leaves that treaty.
  • The text provided is not the final enacted version, so any changes made before Royal Assent cannot be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to match local-election candidacy rules with international treaty agreements.
  • Adding eligible nationals to the existing rules could give people from the listed countries a route to stand for local office, subject to the same other qualifications.
  • A required process for adding countries could make future treaty-related changes without requiring another bill.

Case against#

  • Eligibility is not based only on nationality: the immigration-leave condition may exclude some nationals of a listed country.
  • The bill does not set out the full candidacy process or explain how the new rule works alongside all existing qualifications.
  • The rule requires a country to be added once the treaty conditions are met, but does not require the treaty to have been ratified before it is added. That could make the timing of the change unclear.
  • The supplied material gives no cost estimate for administering the regulations.