Summary#
The Hunting with Dogs (Scotland) Bill, as passed, is the Hunting with Dogs (Scotland) Act 2023. It repeals and replaces the Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Act 2002, under which hunting a wild mammal with a dog was already an offence. Its stated goal is to prohibit that hunting, subject to listed exceptions, and to prohibit trail hunting.
- Hunting a wild mammal with a dog is an offence unless an exception applies. The exceptions cover specified forms of wildlife management, sport, animal welfare and environmental work, with conditions such as limits on dog numbers and permission to use the land.
- A person who knowingly allows another person to hunt on their land, or knowingly allows another person to use a dog they own or are responsible for, can also commit an offence.
- Trail hunting—directing a dog to follow a laid scent from a wild mammal or one that mimics its scent—is an offence, with a limited exception for training dogs for a lawful purpose.
- Scottish Ministers can license more than two dogs for certain management or environmental work. They must apply conditions, including limits on the number of dogs and guns; an environmental licence also requires a significant or long-term environmental benefit and no effective alternative solution.
- The Act gives constables search and seizure powers and lets courts make orders affecting dogs or horses connected with offences, or disqualify a person from specified activities involving dogs. These are powers, not automatic outcomes.
What it means for you#
- People hunting, landowners and dog owners: The Act sets out offences for hunting, knowingly permitting it, and trail hunting. A person charged with knowingly permitting hunting has a defence if they show they reasonably believed an exception applied. The maximum penalty for the main hunting offence is 12 months’ imprisonment or a £40,000 fine on summary conviction; on indictment, up to five years’ imprisonment, an unlimited fine, or both.
- People carrying out permitted work: Some activities remain exceptions only if their conditions are met. For example, above-ground management for specified purposes is generally limited to two dogs, requires land permission, and requires the animal to be killed as soon as reasonably possible. Separate rules apply to foxes below ground, injured or dead mammals, sporting activities and environmental work.
- People seeking to use more than two dogs: They may apply for a licence for specified activities; a licence is not guaranteed. Ministers may delegate licensing to Scottish Natural Heritage. Applicants may have to pay a reasonable fee.
- People who own or keep dogs: A court may order a dog’s sale, other disposal or destruction, or disqualify a person from activities involving dogs. These orders are not automatic. The Act includes animal-welfare safeguards, including requiring veterinary evidence before an order for destruction.
- The public: The Act does not ban every use of dogs to find wild mammals. It includes exceptions, including for searching for dead mammals and relieving the suffering of injured mammals.
Money#
The Act requires licensing functions and reviews, but the supplied material gives no public cost estimate.
- Licence applicants may have to pay a reasonable fee set by the relevant authority.
- Scottish Ministers must review the operation of the two licensing sections and publish reports, starting no later than 31 December 2028.
- The Act assigns licensing and enforcement powers, but gives no staffing or operating-cost figures.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material says the Bill reached Royal Assent, but most provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers. No commencement date is supplied.
- The text of the repealed 2002 Act is not supplied. The material confirms that the earlier Act already prohibited hunting wild mammals with dogs, but does not let us verify exactly which detailed rules are new, changed or carried over.
- Terms such as “serious damage,” “reasonable steps” and “significant or long-term environmental benefit” are not defined in the supplied text.
- The Act does not set out detailed application timelines or appeal routes for licences. It allows licence conditions and information requirements to be set by the relevant authority.
- Ministers may change the meaning of trail hunting to cover other scents, but only after consultation and approval by the Scottish Parliament.
Case for#
- The Act appears intended to restrict hunting with dogs while preserving specified activities, such as animal welfare work and some wildlife management.
- A possible argument for the dog limits, land-permission rules and humane-killing conditions is that they set clear boundaries for activities that remain allowed.
- Licensing more than two dogs only where the stated tests are met could allow larger groups for some purposes while limiting their use.
- The trail-hunting offence addresses both scents derived from wild mammals and scents designed to resemble them.
Case against#
- One concern is that the exceptions and licensing tests depend on terms that are not defined in the Act, leaving important decisions to licence authorities and, in cases of alleged offences, the courts.
- The Act gives constables powers to search people and premises and seize relevant items. Those powers may raise concerns about intrusion, although the text sets out suspicion requirements and additional rules for entry to premises.
- The Act requires licensing and reviews but does not say how much they will cost or how many staff they will need.
- Because the 2002 Act’s text is not supplied, the available material does not show how much of the replacement changes existing practice.