Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The as-passed Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill would amend the Gender Recognition Act 2004; it would not create a separate gender-recognition agency. Its stated goal is to reform the grounds and process for getting a gender recognition certificate (GRC), which legally recognises a person’s acquired gender. The supplied material does not establish whether the Bill later became law or when its provisions would start.

  • A person aged 16 or older could apply to the Registrar General for Scotland if they have a Scottish birth-register entry or live in Scotland. Applicants would have to declare that they have lived in their acquired gender for six months if aged 16 or 17, or three months if aged 18 or older, and intend to live in it permanently.
  • Applicants would have a three-month reflection period. The Registrar General must grant an application that meets the Bill’s requirements, unless a sheriff orders rejection on specified grounds. Regulations could add application information or evidence requirements.
  • Applicants aged 16 or 17 would have to confirm they discussed the implications with either someone whose role involves advising, guiding or supporting young people, or an adult who knows them personally.
  • The Bill sets out routes for spouses or civil partners to continue their relationship after a GRC, and for people with relevant UK or overseas gender recognition to have it recognised in Scotland.
  • It would add offences for knowingly making materially false declarations or giving materially false information. It also requires ministers to publish guidance, the Registrar General to report application figures, and ministers to review the Act’s operation.

What it means for you#

  • People applying in Scotland: The application would be based on statutory declarations and the other requirements in the Bill. A GRC would recognise the applicant’s acquired gender. The Bill says it does not modify the Equality Act 2010.
  • Applicants aged 16 or 17: They would need to meet the six-month living-in-gender period and confirm a discussion with one of the people described above. The Bill does not require that person to be a health professional.
  • Spouses and civil partners: Their wishes affect whether an applicant who remains married or in a civil partnership gets a full or interim certificate. The Bill provides routes to a full certificate if the relationship ends or the spouse or partner dies.
  • People making false statements: A person who knowingly makes a materially false declaration or supplies materially false information could face up to 12 months’ imprisonment or a fine on summary conviction, or up to two years’ imprisonment or a fine on indictment.
  • Current-law comparison: The Gender Recognition Act 2004 is being amended, but its current text was not supplied. I could not verify which parts of the application process are new compared with current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Bill’s estimated costs.

  • The Bill assigns functions to the Registrar General and requires ministers to publish guidance and carry out a review, but the supplied material gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The Bill sets no fee, spending amount or fine amount; false-declaration offences can carry a fine, but no figure is specified in the Bill.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not say whether the Bill became law or when its provisions would start. Ministers would set commencement dates by regulations.
  • The Registrar General could make regulations adding application information or evidence requirements. Those details are not in the Bill.
  • The Bill does not set out all operational details, such as application forms, processing times or how applicants would be supported through the process.
  • The Bill requires a review after three years from the start of its main application provisions, with a report due within two further years. Its findings are not yet available.

Case for#

  • The Bill appears intended to make legal gender recognition available through a defined application process run by the Registrar General.
  • A possible argument for the declaration-based process is that applicants would not have to meet criteria beyond those set out in the Bill and any later regulations.
  • The reflection period and required declarations provide steps for applicants to consider the application before it is decided.
  • The required review would examine how the process works, including its impact on applicants aged 16 and 17.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the Bill allows applications from age 16, with a six-month period and a discussion with a person who need not be a professional adviser.
  • The Registrar General’s power to add information or evidence requirements by regulation leaves some parts of the application process unsettled in the Bill.
  • The Bill creates serious criminal penalties for knowingly false declarations or information. A possible trade-off is that these penalties may deter false applications but also make the consequences of an error important.
  • The Bill requires a review, but that review would happen only after the new process had been in operation for three years, with a report due later.