Bail and Release from Custody (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Bail and Release from Custody (Scotland) Bill became the Bail and Release from Custody (Scotland) Act 2023. It amends existing laws on bail, prisons, community justice and information for victims; it does not create one new service. Its stated goals include changing how bail is decided and improving planning and support when people leave custody.

  • Courts must grant bail unless there is good reason to refuse it. Refusal requires a specified legal ground and a finding that refusing bail is necessary for public safety or to prevent significant harm to the interests of justice.
  • Before deciding bail at a first appearance, a court must give a local-authority officer the chance to provide relevant information. Courts may also ask the prosecutor for information about risk of harm to the complainer (the person the alleged offence was against).
  • When sentencing, courts must count half of qualifying electronically monitored bail time towards the sentence, after any period the court decides to disregard.
  • The Act changes when some prisoners are released, creates temporary release powers for some long-term prisoners and an emergency power for early release, and requires public bodies to take part in release planning when asked.
  • Scottish Ministers must set throughcare standards. Listed public bodies must follow them, and victim-support workers in prescribed categories may receive some information about an offender if the victim asks or consents.

What it means for you#

  • People accused of offences: Bail is the starting point, but it is not guaranteed. A court may refuse it only under the Act’s tests. In summary cases, risk of absconding or failing to appear can be considered only in specified circumstances, including a previous failure to attend a relevant court diet.
  • People on qualifying electronically monitored bail: If later sentenced to prison or detention, the court must count half the qualifying period, rounded up to whole days. The court can disregard some or all of that period, but must give reasons.
  • People leaving prison: Release dates for some prisoners are moved earlier to avoid Fridays, weekends, public holidays and the day before a public holiday. Certain releases must also avoid Thursdays.
  • Some long-term prisoners: Scottish Ministers may grant temporary release on licence up to 180 days before the prisoner reaches half of their sentence. Ministers must consult the Parole Board first. In another route, Ministers must release a prisoner if directed by the Board. Public safety, victim and family protection, preventing reoffending and reintegration must be considered. This is not automatic release.
  • Public bodies involved in release planning: Local authorities, health boards, Police Scotland’s chief constable, Skills Development Scotland and integration joint boards must, so far as reasonably practicable, respond to a Ministers’ request to help develop, manage or deliver a release plan.
  • Victims and support workers: Some prescribed people who provide support to a victim may receive information about an offender’s release or status. The rules vary by type of information; some allow Ministers to withhold it in exceptional circumstances. This is not a general right for every support worker.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Act’s overall cost or expected savings.

  • The Act requires public bodies to provide information, take part in release planning, follow throughcare standards and prepare reports. It gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • It lets Ministers set standards and make certain regulations, but does not state a total budget for these tasks.
  • It does not set a new tax, fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • Many provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers. The supplied material does not give those dates; some reporting provisions start the day after Royal Assent.
  • The Act sets tests and powers for bail decisions, but the supplied text does not provide decision timelines, an appeal process or detailed operating rules for providing local-authority information.
  • The Act lets Ministers make emergency-release regulations, subject to parliamentary scrutiny. The supplied text does not identify any emergency or say whether this power has been used.
  • The number of support workers eligible to receive victim information depends on descriptions set in regulations. Those details are not in the supplied material.
  • The supplied material does not include the prior versions of the laws being amended, so I could not verify how much of the wording restates existing law and how much changes it.

Case for#

  • The Act makes bail refusal depend on both a legal ground and a finding that refusal is necessary. A possible argument is that this makes the reasons for keeping someone in custody clearer.
  • Giving courts access to local-authority information and allowing them to ask prosecutors about risk to a complainer may help them consider relevant information when deciding bail.
  • Counting half of qualifying monitored-bail time at sentencing recognizes that such bail restricts a person’s movements.
  • Release planning duties and minimum throughcare standards could make public bodies’ roles in preparing people for release more consistent.
  • The emergency power is limited by necessity and proportionality tests, a 180-day maximum early release, exclusions and parliamentary scrutiny.

Case against#

  • The bail test still gives courts important judgment calls, including whether refusing bail is necessary and whether conditions would be adequate. The supplied text does not set out detailed decision rules.
  • Temporary release of some long-term prisoners can happen before the halfway point, and the Act sets no deadline for decisions. That may make the timing of decisions hard for prisoners and victims to predict.
  • Emergency early release can be made by urgent regulations before Parliament approves them. It is limited, but it gives Ministers significant power to change release dates in an emergency.
  • Public bodies must take on release-planning and standards duties, but the Act provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.
  • The throughcare standards must apply to all providers, but the direct duty to comply in this Act is placed on a listed set of public bodies. The supplied text does not explain how standards will apply to other providers.