Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Bill became the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022. It amends existing housing laws to set temporary rent limits and restrict some evictions; its stated goal is to protect residential tenants from rent increases and eviction.

  • The Act set a permitted rent increase of 0% from 6 September 2022 for most private residential, assured, short assured, Scottish secure and student residential tenancies. Ministers may change the permitted rate by regulations.
  • For private residential and assured tenancies, landlords may apply to a rent officer for an increase linked to certain higher property costs. The increase must meet the Act’s conditions and cannot exceed 3%; the tenant or landlord may appeal.
  • The Act temporarily restricts enforcing some eviction orders. It lists exceptions, including certain cases involving substantial rent arrears, criminal or anti-social behaviour, or a landlord’s financial hardship.
  • Scottish Ministers must provide affected tenants with information, advice and support, and review and report on whether Part 1 remains necessary and proportionate.
  • Part 1 was set to expire on 31 March 2023, with powers to extend it to 30 September 2023 and then 31 March 2024, or to suspend, revive or end provisions earlier. The Act also gives Ministers a power to change rent-setting rules when the temporary rent provisions expire or are suspended.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants: The 0% limit generally prevented rent increases for covered tenancies during the period it applied. For private residential and assured tenancies, a landlord could seek a limited increase for specified higher property costs, but an increase required a rent officer’s order. The tenant could appeal.
  • Tenants facing eviction: Some eviction orders could not be enforced for up to six months after they were granted, or until the relevant protection expired or was suspended. This did not prevent every eviction: listed exceptions applied, including some cases of substantial rent arrears. The Act also added financial-hardship grounds for some landlords to seek possession.
  • Student tenants: A landlord could not charge a rent increase above the permitted rate. Any excess was not recoverable from the tenant.
  • Landlords: The rules applied across several tenancy types, but the property-cost application route covered private residential and assured tenancies, not every tenancy. Landlords had to provide evidence and written notice to use that route.
  • Scottish Ministers: They must provide tenant support and report on the temporary provisions. They also have powers to change, suspend or end some rules.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the parent Acts or later regulations. I could not verify the changes against the full current law or establish which temporary provisions are in force now.

Money#

No publicly available information on the estimated public cost is in the supplied material.

  • The Act requires Scottish Ministers to provide affected tenants with information, advice and support, but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • It provides no tax, fee or fine. It allows some landlords to apply for a rent increase tied to specified property costs, subject to limits and an official decision.
  • The text gives no estimate of costs to landlords, rent officers, tribunals or public services.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not show whether Ministers later changed the permitted rate, extended or suspended provisions, or used the rent-setting powers. No publicly available information.
  • The text does not give a detailed delivery plan, service standards or funding for tenant information, advice and support.
  • The property-cost exception covers specified costs, including mortgage interest, some insurance premiums and certain service charges. Ministers may change the list. The material does not show whether they did so.
  • The Act requires review and consultation but does not set out how Ministers must measure effects on tenants, landlords or the housing market.

Case for#

  • A temporary rent cap could limit sudden rent increases for tenants during a period of cost pressure.
  • Restricting enforcement of some eviction orders could give affected tenants more time before they lose their homes.
  • Exceptions allow some eviction orders to be enforced, including in specified cases of serious arrears or anti-social behaviour.
  • The property-cost route offers some landlords a way to seek a limited increase when specified costs rise, while requiring evidence and allowing an appeal.

Case against#

  • A 0% rent limit applies broadly to covered tenancies, even where a landlord’s own costs rise; the property-cost exception is limited to certain tenancies and costs.
  • The restrictions could delay landlords from recovering possession even after an eviction order, except in listed cases.
  • The Act’s powers to change, suspend, revive or extend temporary rules leave important details dependent on later ministerial decisions.
  • The supplied material gives no cost estimate for the required tenant support or for administering the rent and eviction rules.