Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland Bill

Summary#

The Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland Bill, as passed, became the Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland Act 2023. It creates a new, independent statutory office; most of the Act’s provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers. Its stated goal is to support system-wide improvement in health care safety and promote the importance of patients’ and the public’s views.

  • The Commissioner must set out and publish principles and a strategic plan, and must create a public Patient Safety Charter describing expected standards and good practice for health care providers.
  • The Commissioner may gather and analyse information, make recommendations, promote awareness and co-ordination, and investigate health care safety issues. In a formal investigation, the Commissioner may require information from any person if doing so is proportionate to the seriousness of the issue.
  • Some information requests are narrower: outside formal investigations, the Commissioner may require relevant information from health care providers and NHS bodies, but not information about an individual.
  • After a formal investigation, the Commissioner must report findings and recommendations to the Scottish Parliament. A person named as a recommendation’s addressee must respond in writing, but need not accept or carry out the recommendation.
  • The Commissioner cannot award compensation, help individuals seek redress, or advise what should be done for a person because of a past incident. Past incidents may still be investigated to inform system-wide improvements.

What it means for you#

  • Patients and the public: The Commissioner must promote the importance of your views and set out how the public can communicate with the office in its strategic plan. The Act does not create a route for resolving individual grievances or obtaining compensation.
  • Health care providers and NHS bodies: They may be required to provide relevant information. In a formal investigation, the Commissioner may require information from any person, subject to a proportionality test and legal protections for information that could be withheld in court. The Commissioner must take the Charter’s expectations into account when considering a provider’s handling of an incident.
  • People named in formal investigation recommendations: If the report identifies you as an addressee and gives a response deadline, you must provide a written response explaining what you have done or plan to do—or why you will not act. The Commissioner may publish the response or publicise a failure to respond.
  • Taxpayers: The Act establishes an office with staff, budget and reporting arrangements. The office must prepare a budget for approval by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body and must publish annual reports and audited accounts.

Money#

No publicly available information gives the total cost of the office.

  • The Commissioner may appoint staff. The Parliamentary Corporate Body may determine the Commissioner’s pay and approve staff terms and conditions.
  • The Commissioner must prepare annual spending proposals for approval. The Act does not give a staffing level or cost estimate.
  • The Commissioner may charge reasonable sums for some services, but cannot charge NHS bodies for providing anything.

What is unclear#

  • The Act does not set a date for most provisions to start; Scottish Ministers must set one by regulations.
  • It does not set detailed criteria for choosing issues to investigate, or a process for individuals to submit complaints or seek help.
  • “Systemic improvement” and the Charter’s expected standards are not defined in the Act. The Commissioner must develop the Charter and principles, after consultation.
  • The Act requires responses to recommendations, not action on them. It does not set out how recommendations will be followed up or what happens if an addressee rejects one.
  • The Act does not explain how this office will interact with other routes for complaints or investigations.

Case for#

  • A commissioner with a system-wide role could examine past incidents to identify safety issues without taking on the separate task of resolving individual grievances.
  • The office can gather information, investigate serious issues, publish findings and make recommendations. These powers could help bring safety concerns into public view.
  • Requiring written responses gives recommendation addressees a duty to explain their decisions, even though they are not required to follow the recommendations.
  • The Commissioner must consult on key documents and give particular consideration to groups whose needs appear under-represented in health care discussions.

Case against#

  • The Act does not require health care providers or other addressees to carry out recommendations. A possible trade-off is that the Commissioner can identify problems without being able to ensure they are fixed.
  • People harmed by an incident cannot use this office to obtain compensation or help pursuing redress. It is unclear how the office’s work will connect with other routes for individual concerns.
  • The information-gathering powers can reach beyond health care providers during formal investigations. The proportionality test and court protections limit that power, but the Act does not set further detailed rules for using it.
  • The Act creates staffing and operating responsibilities without giving a cost estimate, so the public expense is unclear.