Charities (Regulation and Administration) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

As passed, this is the Charities (Regulation and Administration) (Scotland) Act 2023. It amends the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005; its stated purpose is to change parts of the law on charity regulation and administration. The supplied status is Royal Assent, but most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers.

  • OSCR, Scotland’s charity regulator, must publish charity trustees’ names on the Scottish Charity Register, unless it is satisfied that publishing the information would likely jeopardise someone’s safety or security. It must also keep a separate schedule of information about all charity trustees.
  • The Act widens the grounds for disqualification from being a charity trustee and also disqualifies a person from senior management functions in a charity while they are disqualified as a trustee. OSCR may waive some disqualifications.
  • OSCR gains new duties and powers on charity accounts, inquiries and directions. These include making accounts available to the public for at least five years and, in specified cases, directing a charity or a body it controls to take steps.
  • A charity must prepare and send OSCR an annual return, in the form and with the information OSCR requires. OSCR may remove a charity that has not submitted accounts and has not responded, after notice and a three-month opportunity to make contact.
  • Charities involved in a merger may notify OSCR after the transfer of property, rights and liabilities. OSCR must record mergers it is notified about; the Act also sets rules for certain legacies to pass to a successor charity.
  • OSCR may refuse to register an applicant with no or negligible connection to Scotland. If an existing charity fails to comply with a direction to establish more than a negligible connection, OSCR must remove it from the Register.

What it means for you#

  • Charities and trustees: Trustee names generally become public on the Register. A charity or trustee can apply to keep information out of the entry on safety or security grounds, but OSCR must be satisfied the risk is likely. The separate trustee-information schedule is held by OSCR; the Act does not provide public access to it.
  • Trustees and senior charity managers: More types of convictions, court orders, bankruptcy-related measures, sanctions designations and other listed circumstances can disqualify someone from charity trusteeship. The listed offences include offences involving charities, terrorism, money laundering, bribery, perverting the course of justice and misconduct in public office. Disqualification also covers specified senior management roles. OSCR may waive a disqualification, and Scottish Ministers may change the listed grounds by regulations.
  • Charities and people dealing with them: OSCR must make submitted accounts and independent reports available for public inspection for at least five years from the end of the relevant financial year. The Act also requires annual returns. It does not itself set the return’s form or information requirements; OSCR does.
  • Charities under inquiry: OSCR may direct a charity or a body it controls to take specified steps if it finds misconduct or considers action necessary or desirable to protect charitable property or ensure it is properly used. A direction cannot require steps barred by law, expressly barred by the body’s constitution, or inconsistent with the charity’s purposes.
  • Charities merging and people making wills: For a merger that is notified to OSCR, a qualifying legacy is generally treated as passing to the successor unless the will clearly shows a different intention. The timing of notification matters.
  • The public: The Act provides public access to charity accounts, notified-merger records and a searchable record of people removed from office by a Court of Session order. OSCR must withhold a removed person’s entry if disclosure is likely to jeopardise someone’s safety or security.

Money#

The available material gives no cost estimate or funding amount.

  • OSCR must maintain new records and make accounts and merger information available; the Act does not estimate the cost of this work.
  • The Act requires charities to prepare and submit annual returns, but the material does not estimate the cost to charities.
  • No tax, fee or fine change is set out in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The Act does not give commencement dates for most provisions; Scottish Ministers are to set them by regulations.
  • The Act leaves OSCR to decide what information to require for its trustee schedule and annual returns. It does not set a detailed process or timeline for collecting trustee information.
  • “No or negligible connection” to Scotland is not given a fixed threshold. OSCR must consider listed factors, including offices, premises, activities, governing law and where trustees live, as well as other relevant factors.
  • The material does not estimate how much the new duties and powers will cost, or how those costs will be met.
  • It is not clear from the supplied material how these changes will interact with every existing charity-support or oversight process.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to give OSCR more information and tools to identify who is responsible for charities and to act when charity property or administration is at risk.
  • Public access to accounts and a record of notified mergers could make it easier to check a charity’s reporting and changes.
  • The rules for interim trustees, mergers and legacies could help address practical problems when a charity cannot appoint trustees or changes its structure.
  • Wider disqualification rules could prevent people in specified circumstances from holding trustee or senior management roles, while OSCR’s waiver power allows for exceptions.

Case against#

  • Publicly listing trustee names and keeping detailed trustee information creates privacy and safety risks. The Act allows safety-based exclusions from the Register, but does not describe the application process in detail.
  • OSCR’s new direction power is broad: it can require steps beyond a charity’s usual powers, subject to the stated limits. The Act does not set a detailed test for which steps are “expedient” (useful or appropriate).
  • The added reporting, record-keeping and public-access duties may create work and costs for OSCR and charities; the supplied material does not quantify them.
  • Some outcomes depend on OSCR’s judgments, including whether a connection to Scotland is negligible and whether information should be withheld. The Act does not set fixed thresholds for those judgments.