Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act 2023 mainly amends existing Scottish laws; it does not create a new independent agency. Its stated goal is to bring all under-18s within the children’s hearings system and change how children are treated in criminal justice and care. The supplied material says most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers; it does not give those dates.

  • It sets the age of “child” at under 18 for the children’s hearings and criminal justice provisions it changes.
  • It changes when children may be placed in secure accommodation, adds trauma-related duties for children’s hearings, and expands the measures that hearings can include in supervision orders.
  • It changes when criminal courts must seek advice from, or remit a case to, a children’s hearing. It also adds safeguards for children in criminal proceedings.
  • It removes young offenders institutions and remand centres as places to detain children. Local authorities have duties towards detained children similar to those they have towards children in their care.
  • It requires Scottish Ministers to make rules for victim support, including a single point of contact, and to publish standards for secure transportation. Providers and authorities arranging transport must meet the applicable standards.
  • It repeals statutory provisions on the named person service and child’s plans, and changes rules for cross-border placements and secure accommodation services.

What it means for you#

  • Children under 18: The Act brings them within the children’s hearings system and applies child-specific criminal justice provisions to them. It does not change the age of criminal responsibility.
  • Children in hearings or secure accommodation: Hearings must have due regard to the effects of trauma. Emergency placement in secure accommodation is allowed only if at least one listed risk condition applies and the decision-maker considers it necessary after considering other options. The Act also changes the tests for secure accommodation authorisations.
  • Children facing criminal proceedings: Courts must consider steps to help a child take part while safeguarding their welfare. In some cases, courts must seek advice from a children’s hearing or remit the case to it. There are exceptions, including where a child is within six months of turning 18 and referral is not practicable.
  • People affected by a child’s offence or behaviour: The Principal Reporter must, so far as reasonably practicable, tell eligible people about their right to request information. Ministers must make regulations for support services and a single point of contact; the Act does not itself set out the full service.
  • Local authorities and transport providers: Local authorities have duties towards children detained in secure accommodation similar to duties towards children in their care. Providers of secure transportation must meet applicable standards; local authorities and Scottish Ministers must ensure services they arrange meet them.
  • Families and the public: The Act repeals the statutory provisions on the named person service and child’s plans. It does not set out a replacement service in this Act.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Act’s total cost or expected savings.

  • The Act creates duties for Ministers, local authorities and transport providers, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • Regulations may provide for expenses, fees or allowances connected with victim support services.
  • Local authorities must meet specified care duties for detained children, but the supplied material does not estimate the cost.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts’ full current text, so it is not possible to verify how much of each amended rule is new compared with current law.
  • Ministers must make regulations on victim support, secure transport, secure accommodation and cross-border placements. The service details, procedures and some safeguards depend on those rules.
  • The Act does not specify how many children will be affected, how many secure accommodation places are needed, or what resources implementation requires.
  • The Act requires annual reviews of its operation, but does not set out a detailed process for resolving gaps found in those reviews.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to treat under-18s consistently as children across hearings and criminal justice provisions.
  • Trauma-related duties, participation safeguards and limits on emergency secure placements could help protect children’s welfare and rights.
  • Keeping detained children in residential establishments rather than prisons or young offenders institutions, while giving local authorities care duties, could support a more care-focused approach.
  • A required single point of contact and support services could make information and support easier for people affected by a child’s offence or behaviour to access.

Case against#

  • The Act creates duties and powers whose practical detail depends on later regulations; until those rules are made, important parts of the system remain uncertain.
  • Secure accommodation restricts a child’s liberty. The Act sets conditions for some placements, but how decisions are made and reviewed will depend in part on later rules.
  • Expanding child-specific criminal justice provisions to under-18s could require changes in court, care and transport services; the supplied material gives no estimate of the resources needed.
  • The Act repeals the statutory provisions on the named person service and child’s plans without setting out a replacement in this Act.