Wildlife Management and Muirburn (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Wildlife Management and Muirburn (Scotland) Bill was passed as the Wildlife Management and Muirburn (Scotland) Act 2023. It amends the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 and other laws, and creates a licensing system for muirburn; its stated goal is to change how wildlife is managed and how muirburn is made.

  • Glue traps: using, supplying or possessing them becomes an offence unless there is a reasonable excuse or a person is authorised under a scheme. The scheme may authorise them only for public-health protection when no other rodent-control method is practicable.
  • Snares: the Act changes the rules on setting and using snares, including prohibitions on using them to kill animals other than wild birds and on using non-hand-operated snares to take animals other than wild birds. It also provides for specified exceptions; the full schedules and parent Act are not supplied here.
  • Other wildlife traps: people using specified traps to lawfully take or kill wild birds or animals must hold a licence, complete approved training, mark the trap with their licence number and use and monitor it in line with their training. They also need the landowner’s or occupier’s permission.
  • Red grouse: the Act creates a land-based licensing system for killing or taking this bird. Licences may last up to five years and must take account of a code of practice.
  • Muirburn: a person must have and follow a licence to make it. Licences are limited to listed purposes; peatland has narrower permitted purposes and stricter tests. The usual season is 15 September to 31 March.
  • Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers. The dates are not in the supplied material.

What it means for you#

  • People using, selling or possessing glue traps: these activities are offences unless you have a reasonable excuse or are authorised under the scheme. The Act allows the scheme to set application rules, conditions, training and appeals.
  • People using wildlife traps: for traps covered by the rules, you must get a licence and complete approved training. You must mark and monitor the trap as required, and have the landowner’s or occupier’s permission.
  • Landowners, occupiers and people making muirburn: an owner or occupier may apply for a licence for specified purposes. Anyone making the burn must have completed approved training, have regard to the Muirburn Code and give at least seven days’ written notice to the site’s owner and nearby occupiers, subject to exceptions.
  • People managing land where red grouse may be killed or taken: the land must have a licence in the circumstances set out in the Act. A person may rely on a reasonable belief that the owner or occupier holds a licence in certain cases.
  • Police, local authorities and inspectors: police may seek warrants for specified offences. Local weights and measures authorities get powers to investigate glue-trap supply and possession offences. Inspectors may search and seize evidence of listed wildlife offences on non-domestic premises after entering under a relevant power.
  • Current-law comparison: the parent Acts are not supplied, so I could not verify which rules already applied or exactly how much of the amended wording is new.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • Scottish Ministers may require reasonable fees for applications for glue-trap authorisations, wildlife-trap licences and muirburn licences.
  • The Act requires approved training for several activities, but gives no estimate of training, administration or enforcement costs.
  • It does not set out a public funding amount or a new benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The start dates for most provisions are not given. No publicly available information.
  • The regulations, training requirements and codes that will fill in many practical details are not included.
  • The Act does not explain how decision-makers will apply broad tests such as whether a licence is “appropriate,” or how many applications or inspections there will be.
  • The full schedules and the current versions of the amended Acts were not supplied, so the exact scope of some snare and trap rules, and the change from current law, cannot be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce harm to animals by restricting glue traps and snares and setting training and use rules for other traps.
  • A possible argument for licensing is that it makes training, trap identification and landowner permission part of the rules for covered traps.
  • Muirburn licences could allow specified land-management and wildfire-related purposes while requiring training, notice and regard to a code.
  • The red grouse licence system links permission to manage land with a code of practice and requires Ministers to report on the operation of licences and the conservation status of named bird species.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the Act creates offences and licensing duties before the supplied material shows the detailed rules, training courses or decision process people will face.
  • Muirburn on peatland is limited to listed purposes and requires Ministers to be satisfied that burning is necessary and no other vegetation-control method is practicable; applicants may find those tests difficult to apply without further guidance.
  • The Act gives authorities significant inspection and seizure powers. The supplied text does not show how often those powers will be used.
  • Application and training fees are allowed, but no amounts or overall costs are provided.