Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Bill, as passed, is the Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Act 2023. It changes several existing laws, including the Solicitors (Scotland) Act 1980, the Legal Profession and Legal Aid (Scotland) Act 2007 and the Legal Services (Scotland) Act 2010. Its stated goal is a modernised framework for regulating legal services; that goal is not a guaranteed result. Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers, so Royal Assent does not mean they all take effect at once.

  • It sets regulatory objectives and professional principles for legal services. The Law Society of Scotland becomes a category 1 regulator; the Faculty of Advocates and the Association of Construction Attorneys are category 2 regulators.
  • It gives the Lord President powers to review regulators and, in specified circumstances, set targets, direct action, censure a regulator or change its regulatory functions.
  • It creates a route for other bodies to apply to the Lord President to become accredited regulators. An accredited regulator could authorise people to conduct litigation, appear in court or provide other legal services, subject to an approved regulatory scheme.
  • It requires legal businesses that provide legal services to the public for payment to be authorised by the relevant category 1 regulator. The Law Society must make rules to authorise and regulate these businesses.
  • It changes the complaints system and allows the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission to handle complaints about some legal services from providers who are not otherwise regulated.
  • It removes some practising restrictions on law centres, citizens advice bodies and charities providing legal services, and gives their client communications legal privilege in legal proceedings.

What it means for you#

  • People using legal services: Category 1 and 2 regulators must keep free, searchable public registers of the providers they regulate. The Act also provides for complaints about inadequate legal services from some providers who are not practitioners. It does not guarantee that services will be affordable or available.
  • People considering a complaint: The Commission must investigate and determine services complaints, subject to exceptions in the Act. For example, it may decide not to investigate if it considers an offered settlement fair and reasonable and the offer remains open for up to 28 days. A review committee can review certain Commission decisions.
  • Legal businesses and their owners: A business covered by the Act must be authorised to provide legal services to the public for payment. Its regulator’s rules must cover matters including authorisation, practice standards, accounting, insurance and complaints. A breach can lead to sanctions, including financial penalties.
  • Lawyers and other providers: The Act creates offences for some people who falsely claim to be a regulated provider or use the title “lawyer” while offering legal services to the public for payment. The title offence has an exception for services relating to religious law when the person makes that limitation clear.
  • Law centres, citizens advice bodies and charities: The Act removes certain restrictions on solicitors working with them and on their provision of legal services. It does not make these organisations legal regulators.
  • People considering new ways to provide legal services: A body may apply for accreditation, but the Lord President must approve its scheme and the body must be assigned a regulatory category before its authorised providers can exercise the acquired rights.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The Act requires regulators to fund their regulatory work; the Law Society must adequately resource its regulatory committee. The Commission must allocate reasonably sufficient resources to its register of unregulated providers and complaints work.
  • Regulators may charge authorisation fees. The Commission’s rules may set levies and contributions, including contributions from unregulated providers on a register. The amounts are not set out here.
  • Category 1 regulators must maintain compensation funds and require contributions from providers they regulate. The Act does not estimate the funds’ costs.
  • Financial penalties under the legal-business rules are payable to Scottish Ministers. The material does not estimate revenue from penalties.

What is unclear#

  • The start dates for most provisions depend on regulations. The material does not give a timetable.
  • The detailed application, authorisation and complaint procedures depend in part on rules or later regulations. The Act does not set every fee, eligibility test or decision timeline.
  • Scottish Ministers may make regulations specifying which unregulated providers must join the Commission’s register. The material does not identify those providers or the contribution amounts.
  • The available material does not include the full current texts of the Acts being amended. I could not verify which provisions are new rules and which change or restate existing law.
  • The material gives no estimate of staffing needs, implementation costs or ongoing public costs.

Case for#

  • The Act sets consumer protection, access to justice, fair treatment and redress among the regulatory objectives. A possible argument for it is that regulators will have clearer goals to apply.
  • Separate regulatory committees at category 1 regulators are intended to support independent regulation where a regulator also has other functions.
  • Public registers, annual reporting and powers to address regulatory failures could make oversight more visible and accountable.
  • Accreditation could allow additional bodies to authorise providers, while requiring schemes and standards before those providers exercise new rights.

Case against#

  • The Act creates a large system of rules, approvals and oversight powers. Without the later rules, fees and costs, it is difficult to judge how burdensome the system will be for businesses or providers.
  • Some important details—including which unregulated providers must register and how complaints will be handled—depend on later decisions and rules.
  • The Lord President can direct regulators and, in some cases, change their functions. That could help address failures, but it also concentrates significant oversight power in one office.
  • The Act’s goals include affordable services and access to justice, but it does not guarantee those outcomes or set specific measures for achieving them.