Police (Ethics, Conduct and Scrutiny) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Police (Ethics, Conduct and Scrutiny) (Scotland) Bill became the Police (Ethics, Conduct and Scrutiny) (Scotland) Act 2024 after Royal Assent. It amends the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 and the Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2006. Its stated goal is to strengthen police ethics, conduct rules and scrutiny; that goal is not a guaranteed result.

  • The chief constable must prepare and publish a police ethics code, consult specified groups, review the code at least every five years, and ensure constables and police staff read and understand it.
  • The Act adds candour (openness and truthfulness) to police standards, while preserving the reasonable right to claim privilege against self-incrimination.
  • It requires ongoing vetting of constables through regulations and a vetting code for constables and police staff. The rules may lead to conditions, redeployment, demotion or dismissal; the code must set out evidence standards and require written reasons for such decisions.
  • The Scottish Police Authority must keep advisory and barred lists. Four named police bodies must check both lists before employing or appointing someone. Further rules will set out notice, information, and consequences.
  • The Police Investigations and Review Commissioner (PIRC) gains new complaint and review functions, including power to take up some complaints and review police policies. Authorities must respond to certain recommendations.
  • The Act also changes misconduct procedures, makes the Authority liable for unlawful conduct by the chief constable in the same way an employer is liable for an employee, and requires an advisory board for the PIRC.

The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so it is not possible to verify how each change differs from the law already in force. Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers, rather than automatically on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Police officers and staff: They must follow the ethics code once it takes effect. Vetting rules may require them to disclose specified changes in personal circumstances and cooperate with vetting. For staff, the vetting code must provide for periodic checks and checks when a reason arises.
  • Officers and staff facing vetting action: Rules may allow conditions, redeployment, demotion or dismissal. The vetting code must specify evidence types and require written reasons for these actions. The Act does not itself set out the full decision or appeal process.
  • People making complaints: The PIRC may, in specified circumstances, consider a complaint itself, including where it finds reasonable grounds to believe it was not handled properly and considers its involvement in the public interest. The PIRC may also begin some complaint-handling reviews on its own initiative. This does not mean every complaint will be taken over or reviewed.
  • People seeking police employment or appointment: The Authority, Police Service, PIRC and HM Inspectorate of Constabulary in Scotland must check the advisory and barred lists before employing or appointing someone.
  • Police Authority and chief constable: They must respond to certain PIRC recommendations. A response may explain that they will take action, or give reasons for taking none.
  • General public: The Act does not itself create a new front-line police service or a general right to compensation. It creates or expands rules, oversight powers and duties.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Scottish Police Authority must assist the chief constable with preparing the ethics and vetting codes; no staffing or cost estimate is given.
  • The PIRC may pay advisory-board members remuneration and expenses, with Scottish Ministers’ approval; no amount is set.
  • The Act does not state the overall cost of vetting, new investigations or expanded PIRC work.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not say when most provisions will start; Scottish Ministers must set commencement dates.
  • The detailed vetting rules for constables, including frequency, process and appeals, are left to regulations. The first vetting code cannot be consulted on until a draft of the relevant regulations is received, and the code cannot take effect until those regulations do.
  • Further regulations will set key rules for the advisory and barred lists, including notice, removal, information sharing and the consequences of being listed.
  • The Act does not set out a full process or timetable for every new PIRC power. Some details, including procedures for certain investigations, are left to regulations.
  • Without the parent Acts, the available text does not show how much of the amended wording is new or how the changes interact with existing procedures.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to set clearer, public standards for police conduct, with required consultation and regular review of the ethics code.
  • Ongoing vetting and lists could help police bodies identify people dismissed for misconduct or awaiting the outcome of serious allegations before making appointments.
  • Giving the PIRC more ways to examine complaints and police practices could provide additional scrutiny where existing handling is inadequate.
  • Requiring written reasons for vetting action and responses to recommendations could make decisions easier to understand and scrutinise.

Case against#

  • Important safeguards and practical details—especially for vetting, listing and appeals—depend on later regulations, so the Act alone does not show exactly how people will be affected.
  • Vetting can lead to serious consequences, including dismissal and conditions affecting personal circumstances. The bill does not itself set out the full decision process or appeal rules.
  • The PIRC receives wider powers, but some are discretionary and depend on tests such as public interest; the Act does not guarantee that a particular complaint or policy will be examined.
  • The new duties and expanded oversight may require staff and funding, but the available material gives no cost estimate.