Summary#
The bill became the Transvaginal Mesh Removal (Cost Reimbursement) (Scotland) Act 2021. It creates a new Act, rather than amending an existing one, and gives Scottish Ministers the power to make a scheme reimbursing certain costs linked to transvaginal mesh removal surgery. Its stated goal is to enable those reimbursements; the Act does not require Ministers to make a scheme or guarantee payment to anyone.
- The scheme may cover surgery costs, reasonable travel costs for the patient and one person supporting them, and reasonable accommodation and subsistence costs for both. It may also cover other costs specified in the scheme.
- To qualify, surgery must be arranged other than by a health board and must be intended to remove all or part of synthetic mesh originally inserted through the vaginal wall to treat stress urinary incontinence or pelvic organ prolapse.
- The person must have been ordinarily resident in Scotland when the surgery was arranged, when the mesh was implanted, or at both times.
- The surgery must be arranged before a date set in the scheme. That date cannot be earlier than Royal Assent.
- Ministers may set application rules, decide who may apply and receive payments, set decision factors, provide reviews, and require repayment in some circumstances. They must publish the scheme and lay it before Parliament after making it.
What it means for you#
- People who paid for mesh removal surgery: You may be eligible for reimbursement only if the surgery and residence conditions are met and Ministers make a scheme that covers your costs. The Act does not itself promise payment.
- A person who supported the patient: The scheme may cover your reasonable travel, accommodation and subsistence costs in connection with the surgery.
- People whose surgery was arranged by a health board: That surgery does not meet the Act’s definition of qualifying surgery.
- Scottish Ministers: They may make and administer the scheme, or appoint someone to administer it for them. The payment provisions take effect two months after Royal Assent; that does not mean a scheme must start then.
Money#
The Act allows public payments but gives no estimate of their total cost.
- Payments may reimburse eligible surgery, travel, accommodation and subsistence costs, plus any other costs included in the scheme.
- The scheme may set factors for deciding whether to pay and how much to pay. The Act sets no payment amount or overall spending limit.
- No staffing or administration cost estimate is provided.
What is unclear#
- The Act does not say whether Ministers made a scheme, or what costs and people any scheme covers.
- The scheme must set the application deadline, but the Act does not set one.
- The Act allows the scheme to set evidence requirements, decision rules, review arrangements and repayment conditions; those details are not in the Act.
- “Reasonable” costs and “ordinarily resident” are not defined in the supplied text.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the Act is that people who paid for qualifying surgery may be able to recover some of those costs.
- Including travel and accommodation could help address expenses linked to getting surgery, not just the surgery bill.
- Allowing Ministers to set detailed rules in a scheme leaves room to define applications and payments outside the Act itself.
Case against#
- The Act gives Ministers a power, not a duty, to create a scheme. Eligible people are not guaranteed reimbursement.
- The Act leaves key decisions—including the payment amount, application deadline and review process—to the scheme.
- The health-board condition excludes surgery arranged by a health board, and the Act does not explain why that distinction is used.