Summary#
The Scottish Employment Injuries Advisory Council Bill would create a new body corporate, the Scottish Employment Injuries Advisory Council (SEIAC), and amend the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018 and other laws. Its stated goal is to provide expertise about employment-injury assistance; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The bill is listed as fallen, so it did not create the Council or change the law.
- Scottish Ministers would appoint the Council’s chair and 6 to 12 other members. The other members must include equal numbers appointed to represent employers and employed earners.
- SEIAC would research and report on employment-injury assistance, and scrutinise Scottish Ministers’ proposals for regulations under section 33 of the 2018 Act. It would have to consult affected current or former employed earners and their representatives, including trade unions and relevant charities where they exist.
- Ministers generally could not put those draft regulations to Parliament for approval until SEIAC reported or three months had passed. Ministers could act sooner if they considered it urgent, but would have to explain why to Parliament.
- SEIAC would have a right to access relevant information held by named public bodies and institutions, and could require assistance or explanations. Existing laws that restrict disclosure or assistance would still apply.
- The bill would remove certain scrutiny and reporting functions about employment-injury assistance from the Scottish Commission on Social Security. It would also apply public-body rules to SEIAC, including freedom-of-information rules.
What it means for you#
- People with workplace injuries or diseases: The bill would not itself create or change a benefit, or provide a new front-line service. For the covered regulations, SEIAC would have to consult current or former employed earners with experience of workplace injury or disease risk, and their representatives.
- Employers and workers: Their representatives would have equal numbers of seats among the Council members other than the chair. Ministers must also consider whether the Council as a whole has specified experience, including employment-injury policy, research, law, medicine and disability.
- Public bodies and institutions: If the bill had become law, listed bodies—including Scottish Ministers, local authorities, universities, colleges and health boards—would have had to provide relevant information, assistance or explanations when SEIAC reasonably required them, subject to legal restrictions.
- Scottish Ministers: They would have had to provide the staff and other resources SEIAC required, pay members’ remuneration and expenses as they determined, and follow the consultation and reporting steps for covered regulations.
- The public: SEIAC would have had to make its reports public within one month of sending them. It would also have to hold at least one meeting open to the public each calendar year.
Money#
The bill requires Ministers to provide SEIAC with the staff and other resources it requires, but no cost estimate is included in the supplied material.
- Ministers would also pay members’ remuneration and expenses, and certain fees and allowances for people attending meetings at SEIAC’s request.
- The bill does not set amounts or a budget. The Financial Memorandum is listed among the bill documents, but its contents were not supplied.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the text of the 2018 Act. I could not verify the bill’s amendments against the current Act or fully check how they would change the Commission’s existing functions.
- “Employment-injury assistance” is defined by reference to section 33 of the 2018 Act, whose text was not supplied.
- The bill does not set out how SEIAC must conduct its consultations, or how it would choose whom to consult.
- The Council could receive additional functions by regulations, but the bill does not say what those functions would be.
- The bill gives SEIAC access to “relevant information” held by specified bodies and allows Ministers to add other people or groups by regulations. How that power would be used is not specified.
- The bill would have started six months after Royal Assent, with initial members to be appointed within a further six months. Because it fell, those dates did not take effect.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that a dedicated council could bring research and varied expertise to decisions about employment-injury assistance.
- Requiring consultation with affected earners and their representatives could bring their experience into scrutiny of proposed regulations.
- A report, a delay before most proposals go to Parliament, and a ministerial response could give Parliament and the public more information before they consider those regulations.
- The Council’s independence from government direction or control could support independent scrutiny.
Case against#
- One concern is the cost: Ministers must provide the staff and resources the Council requires, but the supplied material gives no estimate or limit.
- The Council would have broad access to information and could receive additional functions by regulation. The bill does not set out detailed rules for how those powers would be used.
- The urgent route allows Ministers to proceed before the Council reports or the three-month period ends. The bill requires an explanation, but does not require Ministers to accept the Council’s recommendations.
- The bill changes the Commission’s role in this area, but the supplied material does not show how the new Council’s work would interact with the Commission’s other work.