Summary#
The Circular Economy (Scotland) Act 2024 amends several existing laws, including the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 and the Environmental Protection Act 1990. It requires Scottish Ministers to prepare a circular economy strategy and make regulations setting circular economy targets; its stated goal is to support the development of a circular economy.
- Ministers must consult on and publish the strategy, keep it under review and report on progress. The first strategy is due within two years after the relevant provisions start.
- Ministers must make regulations setting targets for themselves. The targets and how progress will be measured are to be set later.
- Ministers may make rules restricting or banning disposal of some unsold consumer goods, and may require suppliers to charge for specified single-use items. These powers do not themselves set a ban or require a charge.
- The Act creates or enables new waste enforcement measures, including civil penalties for littering from vehicles and rules for penalties linked to household waste requirements. It also gives officials search and seizure powers for specified waste offences.
- Ministers must publish a code of practice for councils’ household waste collection and recycling functions. They may set recycling targets for councils, but those targets cannot apply to a period before 1 April 2030.
- The Act applies several public-body laws to Zero Waste Scotland. It does not create a new independent agency.
What it means for you#
- Households: An occupier must take reasonable steps to ensure household waste is transferred only to an authorised person or for authorised transport. A fixed penalty of £200 may be offered for an offence, with Ministers able to change the amount within a stated limit. There are also new warning and civil-penalty rules for certain failures to follow council waste requirements, where the failure has caused, or is likely to cause, a nuisance or harm local amenities.
- Vehicle keepers: A council or other authorised litter authority may impose a civil penalty on a vehicle’s keeper if it is satisfied that litter was dropped from the vehicle. The registered keeper is presumed to be the keeper unless that is disproved. The notice must be issued within three months, and the Act bars separate litter action for the same incident in specified circumstances.
- Suppliers: Ministers may make regulations requiring suppliers to charge for specified items used once or for a short period, and to apply the net proceeds to environmental protection or improvement, or a reasonably similar purpose.
- Businesses and others holding waste or surplus materials: Regulations may require specified people to make information about stored or disposed items publicly available. Domestic activities are excluded from this regulation-making power.
- Councils and waste authorities: They must follow the household-waste code of practice. They may also be given recycling targets and new enforcement or information duties through later regulations.
- People whose property is seized: Waste officials may seize vehicles and their contents for specified offences if they reasonably believe an offence has been, is being or is about to be committed, and proceedings have not begun. The rules for notice, return or disposal of seized property must be set later.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material; the Act enables duties and enforcement powers, but their costs are not quantified.
- Councils and other authorities may need staff and resources for enforcement, reporting and the household-waste code. The number of staff and costs are not stated.
- Regulations may create charges, civil penalties and fixed penalties. The Act directs net proceeds from any single-use-item charges to environmental or similar purposes.
- The Act does not specify the cost of preparing and monitoring the strategy, targets or infrastructure report.
What is unclear#
- The targets, measures, timelines and reporting arrangements will be set in later regulations; the Act does not state what the targets will be.
- Ministers have not yet specified which unsold goods could be covered, which suppliers would have to charge, or the items and amounts involved.
- The procedures and amounts for several civil penalties, including vehicle-litter penalties, depend on later regulations.
- The Act does not set out how the new enforcement powers will be staffed or how they will interact with existing programs.
- The supplied material does not include the current text of the Acts being amended, so it is not possible to verify how much of the rewritten or amended wording changes existing law.
- Most provisions start on dates Ministers set by regulations; those dates are not given here.
Case for#
- The strategy, targets and regular reports could give Scotland a shared plan and a way to track progress on reducing waste and keeping goods and materials in use.
- Powers to restrict disposal of unsold goods and charge for specified single-use items could give Ministers tools to reduce avoidable waste. The details would be set through regulations.
- A code of practice could support more consistent household waste collection and recycling across councils, while allowing different rules for different areas.
- The Act requires Ministers to consider the waste hierarchy, just transition, safety, inequality and potential international impacts when preparing the strategy.
Case against#
- Many important effects depend on future regulations. The Act does not itself specify the targets, goods restrictions or single-use charges, so their reach and impact cannot yet be judged.
- Councils and enforcement bodies may take on new work, but the Act provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.
- Search and seizure powers and new civil penalties can affect individuals and businesses. The detailed safeguards for seized property and several penalty procedures are left to later regulations.
- The Act creates several powers to make rules but does not explain how they will fit with all existing waste and recycling arrangements.