Summary#
The Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) (Scotland) Bill became the Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) (Scotland) Act 2024. It creates a new law; it does not amend the Abortion Act 1967. Its stated goal is to create safe access zones around premises providing abortion services.
- For each protected premises, the Act sets a zone covering the premises, any public area of its grounds, and public areas of land within 200 metres of the site boundary. The Scottish Ministers must publish and maintain a list with maps and start dates.
- In a zone, it is an offence to act with the intention of, or recklessly in a way that has the effect of, influencing someone’s decision about abortion services, impeding access or provision, or causing related harassment, alarm or distress.
- Similar conduct can be an offence in a non-public area between the premises and the zone boundary if it is capable of being seen or heard by someone in the zone. Seeing or hearing an electronic recording or transmission does not count.
- Operators must notify Ministers when abortion services are due to start or stop at premises. Ministers may extend or reduce a zone; extensions require at least 14 days before taking effect, while reductions can take effect no earlier than the list update.
- The Act allows exceptions for permitted accompaniment, providing abortion or other health care, and conduct lawful as peaceful picketing. Ministers must review the Act’s operation and effectiveness after the first two years, and then after each later three-year period.
What it means for you#
- People accessing or providing abortion services: The law protects people in the zone from the specified conduct. It does not ban every protest, conversation, or expression of opinion near a premises; the offence depends on the conduct, its effect and the person’s intention or recklessness.
- People demonstrating or acting near a premises: The rules also cover some conduct on non-public land within the zone boundary if it can be seen or heard by someone in the zone. The Act does not make every act in that area an offence.
- Health Boards and other operators: Operators must notify Ministers when services are due to start or cease. They must also have regard to ministerial guidance. Operators may apply for a zone extension if they consider the existing zone inadequate.
- Scottish Ministers: Ministers must publish and maintain the zone list, and may extend or reduce zones. They must consult before making those changes and explain changes in a report to Parliament within seven days.
- People accused of an offence: The penalty is a fine: up to the statutory maximum on summary conviction, or a fine on conviction on indictment. The Act does not provide for imprisonment for these offences.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Ministers must maintain the list, consult on zone changes, publish guidance and reports, and arrange reviews. The material gives no cost or staffing estimate.
- Operators have notification duties; the material gives no estimate of any related costs.
- The Act creates fines for offences but does not state a fine amount for conviction on indictment.
What is unclear#
- The Act’s main provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers in regulations. The supplied material does not give that date.
- The supplied material does not describe what protections or procedures applied under existing law before this Act.
- The Act does not define terms including “influencing” or “reckless,” or set out a process for investigating or deciding individual cases.
- It does not set decision deadlines or an appeal process for zone changes.
- The Act initially covers specified hospital premises and approved places, with an exclusion for places forming part of a specified approved class. Ministers may later change the definition by regulations, but the material does not say whether they will.
- The material does not explain how the later reviews will measure the Act’s effectiveness.
Case for#
- The Act appears intended to protect people seeking or providing abortion services from conduct that deters access or causes related distress.
- A fixed 200-metre starting zone makes the protection easier to identify, while mapped boundaries tell the public where each zone applies.
- The power to extend zones could allow Ministers to respond where a standard zone does not adequately protect people.
- The exceptions preserve specified conduct, including providing health care and lawful peaceful picketing.
Case against#
- The offence covers conduct that influences a person’s decision, as well as conduct that impedes access or causes distress. The Act does not define “influencing,” which may leave uncertainty about where lawful expression ends and an offence begins.
- Ministers can extend or reduce zones, and may extend other zones when extending one. Although consultation and reports are required, the Act does not set decision deadlines or an appeal process.
- The Act requires new administrative work for Ministers and operators, but the available material gives no cost estimate.
- The Act does not spell out how reviews will assess effectiveness or what evidence they must use.