Summary#
The Social Security (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill became the Social Security (Amendment) (Scotland) Act 2024. It amends the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018; its stated goal is to make further provision about social security in Scotland. Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers, and no start dates are included in the supplied material.
- It replaces the law’s structure for childhood assistance: regulations must set eligibility and what assistance people receive. Existing Best Start Grants regulations are treated as made under the new rules.
- Ministers may create one or more schemes for people with care experience. The Act allows regulations to set eligibility, amounts, applications, reviews, appeals and other rules; it does not itself establish a scheme.
- It changes application and appeal rules, including allowing regulations to treat some late applications as on time and permitting certain appeals after deadlines in exceptional circumstances.
- It changes when a person or representative can be held liable for assistance given in error, and creates a review and appeal process for those decisions.
- It creates a system for recovering some social security assistance from compensation payments for accidents, injuries or diseases. Compensators must apply for a certificate and pay the Scottish Ministers the recoverable amount.
- It gives Ministers powers to request information from people receiving assistance for audit. It also changes inflation-uprating provisions and the Scottish Commission on Social Security’s reporting and administrative arrangements.
What it means for you#
- Families and people seeking childhood assistance: The Act does not itself set new payment amounts or eligibility details; regulations must do that. Non-cash assistance can generally be given only with the person’s agreement, which they can withdraw. Some deductions from ongoing assistance may be allowed in specified circumstances.
- People with care experience: Ministers may set up assistance schemes, but the Act does not guarantee that a scheme will be created or set its benefits.
- Applicants and people challenging decisions: Regulations may allow late applications for several types of assistance to be treated as timely. For some late re-determination requests and appeals, the First-tier Tribunal can allow a case to proceed if it finds exceptional circumstances. These are powers for rules and decisions, not automatic extensions.
- People asked for audit information: Ministers may request information about entitlement and payments. If you do not provide it by the deadline, they may suspend your assistance, but must make another request at the same time. You may have a supporter present unless that wish is unreasonable. If disability means you need help to take part effectively, Ministers must ensure independent advocacy is available. Ministers need withdraw a request only if they decide you have a good reason; that decision is final.
- People who received assistance in error: Ministers may seek repayment only if the error was the person’s or representative’s fault, or was one the person could reasonably be expected to notice. The person must have benefited for a claim against them; a representative may be liable if the person did not benefit. Liability cannot exceed the difference between what was paid and what should have been paid.
- People receiving compensation: In covered cases, the compensation payment is reduced by specified assistance linked to lost earnings, care costs or mobility. The compensator pays the recoverable amount to the Scottish Ministers; the Act does not make the injured person repay it directly.
Money#
No publicly available information on the Act’s estimated public cost or savings.
- Ministers must ensure independent advocacy is available for eligible people responding to audit requests; no staffing or cost estimate is supplied.
- The compensation system requires certificates, calculations and payments to the Scottish Ministers. The Act does not estimate administrative costs or the amounts likely to be recovered.
- It does not set a new tax or fee in the supplied text.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not give commencement dates for most provisions or the regulations that will set their detailed rules.
- The care experience schemes’ eligibility, amounts and start dates are not set in the Act.
- The audit rules—including request deadlines, categories exempt from requests and what counts as a good reason to withdraw a request—are left partly to regulations.
- The parent 2018 Act was not supplied, so the exact difference from current law cannot be checked for every amendment, including the net effect of the changes to uprating duties.
Case for#
- The Act could make social security rules more adaptable by letting regulations set detailed eligibility and payment rules for childhood and care experience assistance.
- It gives people routes to challenge some process decisions and late appeals, while requiring reasons and written records for several decisions.
- The error-repayment rules limit liability to cases involving fault or an error a person could reasonably be expected to notice, and cap repayment at the excess assistance.
- Recovering assistance from related compensation could reduce the risk of compensation and public assistance covering the same listed loss.
Case against#
- Several important choices—especially the design of care experience assistance and audit rules—are left to future regulations, so the Act alone does not show who will qualify or what they will receive.
- Suspending assistance for failure to answer an audit request could affect a recipient before the underlying audit issue is resolved. The withdrawal decision has no appeal under the provisions supplied.
- The compensation rules can reduce a person’s payment, potentially to nil under a listed compensation head, and the Ministers may change the assistance covered by regulations.
- The Act creates new administrative duties and processes, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or detail on the staff and systems needed.