Housing (Cladding Remediation) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Housing (Cladding Remediation) (Scotland) Bill was passed as the Housing (Cladding Remediation) (Scotland) Act 2024. It creates a new law, rather than amending an existing Act. Its stated goal is to identify and address risks to human life from cladding on certain residential buildings; it does not guarantee that every such building will be assessed or repaired.

  • Scottish Ministers may arrange assessments and work to address risks identified in assessment reports. The Act defines the buildings covered as flatted buildings with a dwelling, external wall cladding, at least 11 metres in height, and construction or development between 1 June 1992 and 1 June 2022. Ministers may change the types of buildings covered by regulations, within limits.
  • Ministers must maintain a register recording assessment findings and, when they are satisfied necessary work is complete, the date of that decision. They may charge for access.
  • Ministers may arrange urgent work if a risk to life is so immediate that it would be inappropriate to use the usual process. They may also require occupants to leave premises in specified danger circumstances.
  • The Act lets Ministers create one or more responsible developers schemes by regulations. A scheme could require eligible developers to carry out or contribute money towards assessments and work. Regulations could also restrict some development or building approvals for eligible developers who are not members.
  • The Act creates duties to engage with owners and occupiers and to report progress to Parliament. It also creates offences, including for providing certain false information or occupying evacuated premises.

What it means for you#

  • Owners and occupiers: Ministers may arrange assessments and remediation work, but the Act does not require them to assess or repair every building within its definition. Owners must generally receive advance notice before assessment entry or work; owners may appeal a decision to arrange remediation work. Occupiers must be informed and given opportunities to ask questions under “best endeavours” duties (a duty to try as hard as reasonably possible).
  • Residents facing evacuation: Ministers may require you to leave if, in their opinion, there is a substantial risk to life, or if work may endanger occupants. A tenancy is not treated as ended or changed just because someone leaves under such a requirement. Occupying premises while forbidden can lead to a fine, imprisonment for up to three months, or both.
  • People with disabilities: Ministers may make regulations about personal emergency evacuation plans for disabled occupants of buildings covered by an assessment. The Act does not itself set out those plans.
  • Developers: If regulations establish a scheme, developers with the connection to a building set by those rules may have to join or contribute. The Act itself does not establish the scheme or set the contribution amounts.
  • People asked for information: Ministers may require information reasonably needed for assessments or the register. Failure to comply without a reasonable excuse can be an offence. The Act also allows entry powers for assessment or work, but force to enter requires a sheriff’s or summary sheriff’s warrant.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public cost, savings, or total contributions is included in the supplied material.

  • Ministers must maintain the register and prepare and publish progress reports once the relevant provisions are in force.
  • Ministers may charge for access to the register.
  • Future scheme regulations may require membership fees and financial contributions from developers. The amounts and how costs would be shared are not set in the Act.
  • The Act permits Ministers to arrange assessments and remediation work, but the supplied material gives no spending estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not give commencement dates for most provisions. The Act says they start on dates set by Ministers; the provisions for progress reports also have a separate start-date mechanism.
  • No scheme regulations are supplied, so who would qualify as a developer, how much members might pay, and what restrictions would apply to non-members remain unknown.
  • The Act does not set out a general process requiring Ministers to assess each eligible building, or timelines for assessment and remediation.
  • The supplied material does not explain how the powers and any developer scheme would interact with existing cladding or building-safety work.
  • Ministers may make evacuation-plan regulations, but the Act does not specify their content or when they would be made.

Case for#

  • The Act gives Ministers powers to arrange assessments and repairs where reports identify risks to human life, including a separate route for urgent work.
  • A central register can record findings and whether Ministers are satisfied that necessary work is complete.
  • A developer scheme could make people in the building industry contribute to assessment and remediation costs, rather than leaving the scheme’s full cost with the public.
  • Engagement duties and progress reports could give residents information and Parliament a view of work underway.

Case against#

  • The Act gives Ministers powers to act but does not require assessment or remediation of every building that meets its definition. The pace and coverage will depend on how the powers are used.
  • The actual developer scheme, including fees, contributions, and possible restrictions on development or approvals, is left to future regulations.
  • Evacuation powers can require people to leave their homes, and the Act does not specify compensation or alternative accommodation.
  • The Act permits significant access and information powers. Although it includes notice rules, exceptions, and warrant safeguards for forced entry, the supplied material does not detail how these powers will be used in practice.