Summary#
The Scottish Languages Bill was passed as an Act. Its short-title provision names it the Scottish Languages Act 2024, although the supplied text also refers to a “Scottish Languages Act 2025.” It amends existing laws, including the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Act 2005 and education laws; its stated goal is to support Gaelic and Scots and education in both languages.
- Gaelic and Scots are given official status in Scotland. The text says this does not change the status of other languages or the operation of other laws.
- For Gaelic, Scottish Ministers must set targets in a national strategy, and must bring forward regulations setting standards for relevant public authorities. Ministers may issue directions, and may act to enforce duties under the Gaelic law.
- Local authorities must consider whether parts of their area meet a test for designation as an area of linguistic significance. If an authority decides not to propose a designation in certain cases, it must publish its reasons.
- Education authorities must promote Gaelic education and Scots language education. The Act also sets processes for assessing requests for Gaelic-medium education and the viability of all-Gaelic schools; a viability finding triggers a duty to take reasonably practicable steps to establish a school.
- Scottish Ministers may give grants or loans to support Gaelic or Scots. They must also review support for Sabhal Mòr Ostaig, including its funding and whether it should receive a particular designation under existing law.
What it means for you#
- People using Gaelic or Scots: Official status does not itself create a general right to use either language in every public service. The Act gives public bodies duties and powers relating to support and use.
- Parents and children seeking Gaelic education: A parent can request an assessment of Gaelic-medium primary education or Gaelic-medium early learning and childcare. The education authority must assess the need within six months, subject to an exception for some repeat requests. A request does not guarantee that provision will be established.
- Communities seeking an all-Gaelic school: A parent, Bòrd na Gàidhlig or Comann nam Pàrant (Nàiseanta) can request a viability assessment. If the authority finds a school viable, it must take reasonably practicable steps to establish one, with a timetable stated in its assessment.
- Education authorities: They must plan for Gaelic education, support access to Gaelic-medium education in another authority’s area where the Act’s conditions apply, and set catchment areas for schools providing it. They must also promote Scots language education in schools under their management.
- Public authorities: For Gaelic, they must have regard to promoting and supporting use of the language and developing Gaelic culture. For Scots, they must have regard to the Scots strategy and relevant guidance. These are duties to consider those matters, not guarantees of a particular outcome.
- School staff and pupils: When Scottish Ministers produce English-language school materials, they must consider whether to produce Gaelic or Scots versions. The Scottish Qualifications Authority must ensure an appropriate number and range of qualifications are available through Gaelic.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Ministers may give grants or loans for Gaelic or Scots support, on conditions they choose; no amount is specified.
- The Act requires new planning, reporting, assessment and review work by public bodies, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- It does not specify the funding required to establish an all-Gaelic school or to support Sabhal Mòr Ostaig.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the amended parent Acts as they stood before this Act. I cannot verify which duties or processes are new and which change existing law.
- The text does not give a start date for most provisions: they are to start on dates set by Scottish Ministers. It says the final provisions start the day after Royal Assent.
- The text does not define what counts as an “appropriate” number and range of Gaelic qualifications, or fully set out how Gaelic and Scots education will be delivered.
- The short-title provision says “Scottish Languages Act 2024,” while other parts refer to a “Scottish Languages Act 2025.” The supplied material does not resolve this inconsistency.
- The text does not specify the budget, staff numbers or detailed delivery arrangements for the new duties.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give public bodies clearer duties and planning tools to support Gaelic and Scots, rather than relying only on broad statements of support.
- Gaelic targets, public reporting and possible ministerial directions could make progress and compliance more visible.
- Assessments of demand and school viability could help authorities plan provision around local needs.
- Making a range of qualifications available through Gaelic could support learning in the language beyond school.
Case against#
- The Act creates substantial duties and processes without setting out their costs or funding.
- Official status may create expectations, but many duties are to promote, support or have regard to a language; the text does not guarantee a specific level of service.
- The Act gives Ministers powers to set standards and direct authorities, while leaving important details to later regulations, guidance and decisions.
- Authorities must assess whether an all-Gaelic school is viable, but the result may depend on factors such as costs, premises and teacher recruitment; the Act does not guarantee a school in every area that requests one.