Judicial Factors (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Judicial Factors (Scotland) Bill became the Judicial Factors (Scotland) Act 2024 after Royal Assent. It replaces and updates parts of the law on judicial factors, who are appointed by a court to hold, manage, administer and protect an estate. Its stated goal is to consolidate and update that law; the Act does not guarantee that a factor will be appointed in any particular case.

  • A court may appoint a judicial factor if an estate needs management or other action, and it is not possible, practical or sensible for the person normally responsible to act—or appointing a factor would benefit the estate.
  • Once appointed, the factor generally gets legal control of the estate. The factor’s standard powers include collecting, managing, investing, selling and acquiring property; carrying on a business; employing or dismissing people; borrowing against the estate; and taking legal action. The court may limit these functions or add others.
  • Judicial factors must follow duties and oversight rules, including preparing an inventory and management plan, submitting accounts, and following the Accountant of Court’s directions. The Accountant must supervise them and audit their accounts.
  • Special notice rules apply to charities: the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator must be notified, and the public must generally be told by advertisement when an appointment is sought or considered.
  • The Act also bars courts from appointing a curator bonis in proceedings begun after that provision comes into force, and requires Scottish Ministers to issue guidance on appointments involving missing persons’ estates.

What it means for you#

  • People with an interest in an estate: A factor may be appointed only by a court, but the appointment can transfer the whole estate to the factor. A person with an interest may be notified and may have a chance to object to a proposed distribution.
  • Creditors and debtors: A factor must tell them about the appointment once aware of them. The factor may require people to provide relevant information; recipients generally must comply, subject to exceptions in the Act and data-protection law.
  • Tenants and people working for an estate: A factor’s standard powers include removing a tenant and employing or dismissing people. The court can restrict the factor’s powers in the appointment order.
  • Charities: OSCR and the public must generally be notified when an appointment is sought or considered. The Act also sets notice rules for a proposed distribution of a charity’s estate.
  • Judicial factors: They must act with care, prudence and diligence, take professional advice when appropriate, and generally cannot delegate their functions without authority.
  • People affected by a factor’s decision or conduct: Legal claims from the factor’s acts or omissions are generally paid from the estate. A court can make the factor personally liable if it finds a breach of duty and considers that appropriate.
  • General public: This is not a general front-line service or an automatic scheme for missing people’s estates. A court must decide whether to appoint a factor.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • The estate pays the factor’s remuneration and reasonable outlays. The Accountant sets rates and decides how often each factor is paid.
  • The estate generally pays fees charged by the Accountant, including fees for work under the Act. The Accountant’s fees must cover reasonably incurred outlays.
  • The Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service may pay the Accountant of Court, but the Act gives no amount. Scottish Ministers must issue guidance on missing persons’ estates; no cost is stated.
  • Most of the Act’s provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers. The material does not give that date.

What is unclear#

  • The text provided does not include the previous laws being replaced. It therefore does not show how much of the Act’s appointment rules and powers are new rather than carried forward from existing law.
  • The Act does not set out a general application process, decision timetable or standard way for people with an interest to make representations before appointment.
  • “Missing persons” is not defined in the supplied text, and the required guidance is not included. The Act does not itself say who qualifies or guarantee an appointment.
  • The Act allows Scottish Ministers to change where appointment notices are recorded, including by creating a register. The text does not say whether they will do so or what information would be public.
  • The number of appointments, staffing needs and total public or estate costs are not stated.

Case for#

  • The Act sets out a single, detailed set of duties and oversight rules for judicial factors, including inventories, management plans and account audits.
  • A factor may be appointed where an estate needs action but the person normally responsible cannot sensibly provide it, or where a factor would benefit the estate.
  • The court can tailor a factor’s functions to the case, while the Accountant can supervise the factor and report serious misconduct or failure.
  • Notice rules for charity estates can alert OSCR and the public to proposed appointments and distributions.

Case against#

  • A factor’s standard powers are broad. They include selling estate property, borrowing against it, carrying on a business, removing tenants and employing or dismissing people.
  • The estate bears the factor’s remuneration, reasonable outlays and most Accountant fees. The material gives no estimate of how large these costs may be or how they might affect what remains for people with an interest in the estate.
  • The Act gives the Accountant substantial oversight powers, including the power to instruct a factor, but the supplied text does not set out all practical details of how that oversight will work.
  • The Act requires guidance for missing persons’ estates but leaves key practical questions—such as who counts as missing and how people can seek an appointment—to other rules or guidance not provided here.